Niels Lyhne a guided tour

A Danish dreamer tries to live without God and never quite knows what to put in God's place. The novel follows him through every test the next thirty years can find, including the last one — a priest at his bedside, offered and refused.

The book in brief

Niels Lyhne is the story of a Danish dreamer who tries to live without God and never quite knows what to put in God's place. Jens Peter Jacobsen wrote it slowly, over six years, while dying of tuberculosis. He had trained as a botanist and translated Darwin into Danish before turning to fiction. The novel was published in Copenhagen in 1880, when he was thirty-three. He lived four more years. The book is short — about 250 pages — but covers a whole life in fourteen loosely linked chapters that move by emotional logic rather than incident.

Niels is born on a rural estate in 19th-century Jutland to a poetic, romantically miserable mother and a steady, prosaic father. From childhood he hovers between their two temperaments, drawn to poetry and inwardness. As a boy he watches his beautiful aunt Edele die calmly without faith, and the novel uses her death as the first anchor of his unbelief. As a young man in Copenhagen he loves the older Mrs. Boye, a worldly widow who treats him as a man for the first time. Years later he falls into a catastrophic affair with Fennimore, the wife of his closest friend. He marries the gentle Gerda late, and loses her, and loses their child, and finally enlists in the Second Schleswig War and is shot. The novel ends at his deathbed, where a priest is offered to him and he refuses.

It quietly reshaped European literature. Rilke read it as a young man and never stopped reading it; he carried it everywhere, called it one of the two books he could never be without, and recommended it to the young poet of the Letters. Stefan Zweig and Thomas Mann admired it; Freud wrote to Fliess that Jacobsen had struck him deeper than anything else he had read in years. It is the great Scandinavian novel about losing one's faith and trying to keep going.

Niels Lyhne, chapter by chapter

Click through the 14 chapters like a tour. Each card picks up where the last left off — a quick way to read Niels Lyhne in five minutes. Open any book in depth, or jump straight into the reader.

Kapitel I1 of 14
Kapitel I

Bartholine's marriage

Bartholine is the eldest daughter of the Blid family — practical, prosperous, devout in the lukewarm way of country people. She is not of their kind. She lives on poems, dreams them, and trusts them above everything else in the world. When Lyhne of Lönborggaard, the young squire of the neighboring estate, comes courting, she falls in love at once: here at last, she thinks, is a man from the great outside world. They are married. The first year is romance; then his appetite for it is exhausted, and hers turns into doubt. By the end of the chapter they are estranged inside the same house, and Bartholine has brought a son into the world. They call him Niels.

Kapitel II

Tug-of-war

In a way the child has brought the parents back together — over his cradle they meet in a common hope. But they are still far apart, and as Niels grows older the difference between them becomes the weather of his childhood. Bartholine reaches him through the imagination, telling him stories of heroes and a stillborn second son she has imagined into a paragon. Lyhne reaches him through the matter-of-fact: the fields, the parish, the slow rhythm of the seasons. Niels feels at home with both at different hours and ashamed of the alternation. The chapter closes on a boy who already understands, without being able to say so, that he lives between two temperaments and has not yet chosen.

Kapitel III

Bigum and Edele

Niels is twelve. He has outgrown the games of his early childhood and begun to read; he and Frithjof, the pastor's son, walk arm in arm telling stories no book has bothered to write. Two new figures arrive at Lönborggaard within the same month. The first is Mr. Bigum, the new tutor — a candidate for holy orders, slightly deaf, devoted to philosophy and the violin, secretly convinced his intellect is wider than that of other men. The second is Edele Lyhne, Lyhne's twenty-six-year-old sister, sent home from Copenhagen on doctor's orders for her lungs. She arrives bored, elegant, contemptuous of the country. The chapter is the long, careful introduction of the two minds that will shape Niels's next years.

Kapitel IV

Edele dies

Edele's health does not improve at Lönborggaard. The local pastor, a kindly man, begins to visit her with the gentle persistence of a clergyman who senses death approaching a soul he believes himself responsible for. He offers her, by stages, the consolations of faith. She receives each one with calm and refuses it. She does not argue. She does not soften. She dies in possession of herself, on her own terms, with no concession made and no unhappiness shown. Niels is at the bedside in the way a boy of twelve is at the bedside of a beautiful aunt he has half worshipped from a distance, and what he takes from the room is the conviction that the consolations of faith are addressed to a fear he refuses to flatter. His atheism begins here. The novel will return to this room again and again across thirty years.

Kapitel V

Erik arrives

Some years after Edele's death, a cousin's son comes to live at Lönborggaard. Erik Refstrup is a few years older than Niels — broad-shouldered, easy in the world, with the kind of confidence Niels does not have and watches with admiration. He intends to be a sculptor. He brings into the quiet house a different temperament from the one Niels has grown up between: not dreamy like his mother, not steady like his father, but sociable, ambitious, bodily, ready. The two boys become close in the way boys do when one has what the other lacks. The friendship will carry Niels through his student years in Copenhagen and through the catastrophe at Mariagerfjord.

Kapitel VI

Mrs. Boye's salon

Niels is now in Copenhagen as a student — vaguely enrolled, more vaguely attending lectures, mostly reading on his own. Erik, ahead of him in the city, takes him one evening to the salon of an older widow named Mrs. Boye. She is witty, unattached, modern; her drawing room is the meeting place of students and minor poets and the better sort of editor. She talks about Heine and the freedoms of married women. Niels, twenty, is given his apprenticeship in the world. The chapter is the long, careful introduction of the woman who will become his first real love and his first real loss.

Kapitel VII

The declaration

In Mrs. Boye's circle the talk one evening turns to God. There are believers in the room and the half-believers who outnumber them in any nineteenth-century salon, and the conversation moves in the patient way of educated people who have agreed not to be rude about it. Niels speaks. He has held his position privately since the bedside of his aunt Edele eight years before; he declares it now in public for the first time. The chapter is small but pivotal: the position is no longer a secret he keeps but a position he is known for. The first cost of holding it begins.

Kapitel VIII

Mrs. Boye, Clarens

Niels and Mrs. Boye become lovers. The novel handles the affair as it handles everything: with patient particularity rather than scandal. They are happy in their way; she is the older partner; he is being formed by her without quite knowing it. Then word arrives from Lönborggaard that Bartholine's health is giving way, and Niels takes his mother south for the journey she has dreamed of since her girlhood — through Hamburg and the Alps to Italy. She sees Lake Garda. She is happy. She dies at Clarens. Niels comes back to Copenhagen to find his life with Mrs. Boye no longer quite the life it was.

Kapitel IX

Christmas Eve atheism

It is the Christmas after Niels's mother's death and Mrs. Boye's marriage to another man. Niels does not go home to Lönborggaard. He spends Christmas Eve in town with Hjerrild, the older editor he has known since Mrs. Boye's salon. The two of them sit late over a bottle and argue. Hjerrild defends a life lived without God but quietly — privately, courteously, without scandal. Niels insists that the position must be held in public if it is to be held at all. The chapter is the novel's clearest sustained dialogue on what atheism costs and how it should be borne.

Kapitel X

Erik married

Erik has married. The young woman is Fennimore — younger than the friends, gentle, intelligent, attached to Erik in a way that has not yet been tested. They have taken a small manor in the village of Fjordby on Mariagerfjord, in north Jutland. Niels visits. He finds Erik no longer working — the sculptor's tools laid by, the studio empty, drink at the elbow more often than is good — and Fennimore, in the long days of the country, increasingly alone with herself. The chapter is the patient setup of the catastrophe.

Kapitel XI

The catastrophe

The affair begins almost without a decision. Niels and Fennimore — the lonely wife, the half-sleeping guest — fall into it across a few summer weeks while Erik is in the village or in his studio or, more often, neither. Then, on a drive home from town in bad weather, Erik's carriage overturns and he is killed. Fennimore turns on Niels with a fury the novel takes seriously: she calls him by every name his behavior has earned and refuses to see him again. Niels leaves Mariagerfjord. The chapter is the catastrophe the book never recovers from, and it is the one Niels does not.

Kapitel XII

Riva

Niels does not go straight back to Lönborggaard. He travels — Germany, Switzerland, northern Italy — for the better part of a year, in the way of men who are trying to outrun a chapter they have just lived. At Riva on Lake Garda he stays for some weeks. He meets Madame Odéro, an opera singer recovering her voice after illness; they walk the lake together; they sit in cafés in the long Italian evenings; they conduct the kind of half-romance the novel does not pretend is more than what it is. She returns to her stage. He goes home.

Kapitel XIII

Gerda and the prayer

Back at Lönborggaard, Niels marries late. Gerda is the daughter of a neighboring family — gentle, religious, much younger than he is — and the marriage is, against the evidence of the novel, a quiet happiness. They have a son. Then Gerda's health gives way and she dies, frightened, having lost her faith on her deathbed. A year later the son falls ill. Niels — modern, secular, twenty years past Edele's deathbed — finds himself praying for the boy. The boy dies. Niels gets up from beside the bed and never prays again. The novel's most exposed test of his atheism is in this room.

Kapitel XIV

The deathbed

War comes. In the spring of 1864 Denmark fights Prussia and Austria over Schleswig and loses badly. Niels enlists — partly out of patriotism, partly out of the long ache to do something he cannot live inside his head. He is shot in a minor engagement and brought back to a field hospital with a wound that will not heal. A priest is offered to him in the last hours. He sends the priest away. The novel ends. Jacobsen does not present the refusal as triumph. It is simply, at the end, what Niels does.

Key themes

5 threads that hold the book together. Full analysis →

The atheism that does not console

Niels casts off God after watching Edele die calmly without faith, and the novel follows him through every test the next thirty years can find. He refuses each time, including at the end, when a priest is brought to his bedside and he sends the priest away. Jacobsen does not present this refusal as triumph.

The long arc of disillusionment

Niels stakes his life on the proposition that beauty, feeling, dreams, and poetry can stand in for what religion used to provide. The novel respects the bet. And then, with the patience of a man who has been watching his own death approach for years, Jacobsen tests the bet against everything that actually breaks a person.

Poetry as failure

Niels is a man who lives mostly inside his own head. He plans a poet's life, drafts speeches he will never deliver, falls in love with women he then watches in his imagination instead of meeting in the room. The novel is the ancestor of every later fiction about the over-examined inner life.

Women as horizon

Edele, Mrs. Boye, Fennimore, Gerda — each a different kind of loss. The novel keeps placing women at the edge of Niels's life as figures of possibility, and each time the possibility closes. The pattern is part of what the book is saying about him.

Denmark as setting

Lönborggaard at the start, Copenhagen in the middle years, the manor at Mariagerfjord, the war of 1864 at the end. The novel is set in a particular country at a particular moment, and the country itself does some of the work the plot does not.

Key figures

The 6 who matter most. More in the full character guide.

Niels Lyhne
The dreamer

The son of a poetic mother, Bartholine, and a steady, prosaic father. He grows up reciting his mother's verses and watching his aunt Edele die without faith. He moves to Copenhagen, studies vaguely, falls in love repeatedly, becomes an atheist on principle, marries late, loses his wife and child, and enlists in the war of 1864. He spends most of his life inside his own head. The novel measures, patiently, what that costs him and the people who love him.

Bartholine Lyhne
The mother

Niels's mother. She married a steady country gentleman believing he would carry her into the world of poetry she dreamed about, and discovered he had no such intention. She lives most of her life inside the books she reads and the verses she recites to her son. She is the source of Niels's inwardness and the first warning the novel gives about it. Her late trip with him to Lake Garda, where she finally sees the Italy she had imagined for forty years and dies at Clarens shortly after, is one of the book's quietest scenes.

Edele
The aunt who dies without God

Niels's young aunt, his father's sister. She comes to Lönborggaard from Copenhagen to recover her health and is courted ineffectually by the local pastor in the language of consolation. She dies without conceding any of it. Her calm refusal to accept the pastor's offers is the moment Niels's atheism is born. She is on the page only briefly, but the novel returns to her again and again, as the standard against which Niels measures every later test of his unbelief.

Mrs. Boye
The widow

An older Copenhagen widow, witty, worldly, and unattached. She takes Niels seriously as a man for the first time and conducts a relationship with him that he is too young to understand. She talks about books and Paris and the freedoms of married women. She eventually sees that he is not the partner she needs and lets him go; she marries another man, and Niels learns it in a newspaper. The relationship leaves him more complicated than it found him, which is exactly what such relationships are for in a novel of this kind.

Fennimore
The catastrophe

Niels's friend Erik's wife. The novel's most devastating relationship: Niels visits Erik, who has stopped working and started drinking, and Fennimore, who is lonely and bitter, falls into an affair with Niels almost without deciding to. When Erik dies suddenly in an accident on the road home, the affair collapses under what they have both done. Fennimore turns on Niels with fury the novel takes seriously. It is the chapter the book never quite recovers from, and it is the one Niels does not.

Gerda
The late marriage

The young woman Niels marries late, after years of drifting. She is gentle, religious, and unworldly. She and Niels have a son. She loses her faith on her deathbed and dies frightened. Their son dies soon after. Niels sits with each of them through their last hours — the test the novel has been preparing for him since Edele's death. What he does and does not do at those bedsides is the moral center of the second half of the book.

Go deeper

Open Niels Lyhne in the reader →