Vol II · Pt II · Ch 17 of 96

Chapter 17 — That In Times Marked By Equality Of Conditions And Sceptical Opinions, It Is Important To Remove To A Distance The Objects Of Human Actions

When faith dies, the future shrinks. Tocqueville argues that in sceptical democratic ages, the moralist's duty is to push the objects of human action as far into the future as possible — to give people a reason to care about what happens after tomorrow.

Summary

A dense and important chapter that argues for the social function of long-term thinking in sceptical democratic societies. Religious faith naturally orients people toward distant goals — eternal happiness — and this trains them to defer immediate desires, sustain long efforts, and build things that last.

When faith weakens, the horizon of human action contracts to the immediate. People begin to live day to day, chasing small pleasures, unable to sustain the effort required for great undertakings.

In a democratic society already inclined toward restlessness and material preoccupation, this contraction is especially dangerous. The moralist's and legislator's task is therefore to find secular analogues for the distant goals that religion provided — to give democratic citizens a reason to think and act across generations.

Appears
Themes
All 96 chapters — click to jump
  1. Vol I · Pt I · Ch 1Tocqueville opens by announcing the central observation of everything that follows: equality of conditions is the generative fact...
  2. Vol I · Pt I · Ch 2This chapter functions as a geographical prologue — Tocqueville the traveller establishing the physical stage before the political...
  3. Vol I · Pt I · Ch 3This is one of the most important chapters in Volume I. Tocqueville argues that the origin of a nation is the most important...
  4. Vol I · Pt I · Ch 4Tocqueville's method is sociological before sociology existed: he begins with social condition — the fundamental arrangement of...
  5. Vol I · Pt I · Ch 5A short but essential chapter. Tocqueville explains that popular sovereignty is not a uniquely American invention — it lies at the...
  6. Vol I · Pt I · Ch 6The longest chapter in Volume I and arguably the most important for understanding Tocqueville's political theory. He examines the...
  7. Vol I · Pt I · Ch 7Tocqueville identifies judicial review — the power of courts to strike down laws as unconstitutional — as one of the most...
  8. Vol I · Pt I · Ch 8A technical but revealing chapter on the American system of political jurisdiction — the process by which officials can be removed...
  9. Vol I · Pt II · Ch 1The longest chapter in the book, covering the entire structure of the federal government — the origins of the union, the bicameral...
  10. Vol I · Pt II · Ch 2A short, decisive chapter. Tocqueville makes the empirical claim that American self-government is not a formality but a reality...
  11. Vol I · Pt II · Ch 3Tocqueville distinguishes between parties that contest fundamental principles — the kind that make revolutions — and parties that...
  12. Vol I · Pt II · Ch 4A candid and somewhat counterintuitive chapter. Tocqueville is not a press enthusiast — he finds American newspapers violent...
  13. Vol I · Pt II · Ch 5One of Tocqueville's most famous observations: Americans associate. For every purpose — moral reform, literary improvement, road...
  14. Vol I · Pt II · Ch 6Tocqueville turns from institutions to practice, observing how American democratic government actually operates — its quality of...
  15. Vol I · Pt II · Ch 7Tocqueville turns to what democracy delivers in practice, against the persistent aristocratic objection that it produces mediocre...
  16. Vol I · Pt II · Ch 8The most famous and most controversial chapter of Volume I. Tocqueville argues that majority rule, taken to its logical...
  17. Vol I · Pt II · Ch 9Having established the danger of majority tyranny, Tocqueville now identifies the institutional arrangements that restrain it in...
  18. Vol I · Pt II · Ch 10The synthetic chapter of Volume I. Tocqueville identifies three categories of cause that explain why American democracy has...
  19. Vol I · Pt II · Ch 11The most morally searching chapter in the book. Tocqueville sets aside the institutional analysis to confront the racial question...
  20. Vol I · Pt II · Ch 12Volume I's conclusion steps back from institutional analysis to panoramic prophecy. Tocqueville surveys the Anglo-American...
  21. Vol II · Pt I · Ch 1Tocqueville's preface explains the shift in texture between the two volumes. Volume I is reportorial — the observations of a...
  22. Vol II · Pt I · Ch 2Volume II begins not with politics but with epistemology — how Americans think. Tocqueville observes that Americans have no...
  23. Vol II · Pt I · Ch 3Having shown that democratic citizens distrust received authority, Tocqueville now confronts the paradox: no one can reason from...
  24. Vol II · Pt I · Ch 4A subtle chapter about the relationship between social equality and intellectual style. Tocqueville argues that aristocratic...
  25. Vol II · Pt I · Ch 5A short but incisive chapter that qualifies the preceding one. Americans, despite their democratic love of abstraction, are...
  26. Vol II · Pt I · Ch 6One of the most important chapters in Volume II, and one that has aged unusually well. Tocqueville argues that religion in a...
  27. Vol II · Pt I · Ch 7A short but provocative chapter. Tocqueville notes that Catholicism, conventionally regarded as the natural ally of monarchy and...
  28. Vol II · Pt I · Ch 8A short, philosophically acute chapter. Tocqueville argues that the democratic habit of thinking in large generalities — which the...
  29. Vol II · Pt I · Ch 9A short but foundational chapter on one of modernity's most characteristic ideas: the belief in indefinite human progress....
  30. Vol II · Pt I · Ch 10A chapter defending democracy against the cultural-aristocratic objection that it is incompatible with high culture. Tocqueville...
  31. Vol II · Pt I · Ch 11Tocqueville makes a structural argument about the relationship between democratic society and science. Democratic individuals are...
  32. Vol II · Pt I · Ch 12Tocqueville examines what equality does to the arts and crafts. In an aristocratic society, art is made for patrons who have money...
  33. Vol II · Pt I · Ch 13A short chapter that captures one of Tocqueville's sharpest paradoxes: democratic individuals feel personally insignificant, yet...
  34. Vol II · Pt I · Ch 14One of the richest chapters of Volume II. Tocqueville describes American bookshelves — elementary textbooks, enormous quantities...
  35. Vol II · Pt I · Ch 15A brief, sharp chapter. Tocqueville observes that in aristocratic ages the only path to literary fame is immense exertion — the...
  36. Vol II · Pt I · Ch 16A short but counterintuitive argument. Tocqueville first corrects a misconception: ancient democracy was nothing like modern...
  37. Vol II · Pt I · Ch 17One of the most perceptive chapters of Volume II. Tocqueville is working from observations by educated English visitors who told...
  38. Vol II · Pt I · Ch 18A subtle and ambitious chapter. Tocqueville defines poetry as the search for ideal beauty — not verse as such but the reaching...
  39. Vol II · Pt I · Ch 19A short, brilliantly observed chapter. Tocqueville notices that American business language is clear and almost coarse, but as soon...
  40. Vol II · Pt I · Ch 20A long, carefully argued chapter about theater as a social institution rather than an aesthetic form. Tocqueville's key...
  41. Vol II · Pt I · Ch 21A short but pointed chapter about the philosophy of history implicit in aristocratic versus democratic sensibilities. Aristocratic...
  42. Vol II · Pt I · Ch 22A brilliant piece of political sociology disguised as a chapter about oratory. Tocqueville explains why American congressional...
  43. Vol II · Pt II · Ch 1This chapter opens Volume II Part 2 and states one of Tocqueville's most important and counterintuitive findings. Liberty and...
  44. Vol II · Pt II · Ch 2One of the most important chapters in the book. Tocqueville distinguishes carefully between selfishness — a passionate, vicious...
  45. Vol II · Pt II · Ch 3A brief but important historical observation. Tocqueville notes that the individualism he has described is most intense...
  46. Vol II · Pt II · Ch 4The first of the constructive chapters — after diagnosing individualism, Tocqueville asks how it is resisted. His answer is...
  47. Vol II · Pt II · Ch 5One of the most celebrated chapters in the book. Tocqueville is astonished by the American capacity to form voluntary associations...
  48. Vol II · Pt II · Ch 6A short, elegant chapter making a structural argument about the relationship between newspapers, associations, and local...
  49. Vol II · Pt II · Ch 7A careful argument that civil and political freedom are not separable. Tocqueville begins with the observation that the only...
  50. Vol II · Pt II · Ch 8One of the most morally nuanced chapters of the book. Tocqueville describes 'the doctrine of self-interest rightly understood'...
  51. Vol II · Pt II · Ch 9A subtle chapter that reads American religion through the lens of self-interest rightly understood. American clergy, Tocqueville...
  52. Vol II · Pt II · Ch 10A chapter about the social psychology of material desire under conditions of equality. Tocqueville traces why the passion for...
  53. Vol II · Pt II · Ch 11Tocqueville draws a sharp contrast between how aristocracies and democracies tend to degenerate. Aristocratic excess tends toward...
  54. Vol II · Pt II · Ch 12A short chapter about religious enthusiasm in democratic societies — the camp meetings, the wandering preachers, the sudden...
  55. Vol II · Pt II · Ch 13One of the most psychologically acute chapters in the book. Tocqueville describes what he sees as he travels across America: men...
  56. Vol II · Pt II · Ch 14One of the most politically urgent chapters of the second volume. Tocqueville argues that the desire for material comfort and the...
  57. Vol II · Pt II · Ch 15A long and genuinely moving chapter that shows Tocqueville at his most sympathetic toward American religion. He describes the...
  58. Vol II · Pt II · Ch 16A short, concentrated philosophical chapter making a paradoxical argument: that the obsessive pursuit of material welfare actually...
  59. Vol II · Pt II · Ch 17A dense and important chapter that argues for the social function of long-term thinking in sceptical democratic societies....
  60. Vol II · Pt II · Ch 18A short chapter that reads as a celebration of something Tocqueville genuinely admires in American society: the absence of the...
  61. Vol II · Pt II · Ch 19A sociological chapter explaining why democratic societies systematically favour industry and commerce over agriculture....
  62. Vol II · Pt II · Ch 20One of the most prescient chapters in the book, and one Tocqueville himself treats with particular care. He traces the logic of...
  63. Vol II · Pt III · Ch 1This chapter opens Volume II Part 3 on manners and marks a shift in tone. Tocqueville is now examining the texture of daily social...
  64. Vol II · Pt III · Ch 2A short, elegant chapter contrasting American and English social manners — and arguing that the contrast is entirely explained by...
  65. Vol II · Pt III · Ch 3Tocqueville explains a paradox anyone who has met Americans in Europe will recognize: at home, where all ranks are equal and no...
  66. Vol II · Pt III · Ch 4This two-paragraph chapter ties together the threads on democratic manners, independence, and sympathy. Tocqueville observes that...
  67. Vol II · Pt III · Ch 5One of Volume II's most penetrating sociological chapters. In an aristocratic household, master and servant belonged to parallel...
  68. Vol II · Pt III · Ch 6A compact chapter applying the servant-master analysis to land. In aristocracies, rent was paid not only in money but in respect...
  69. Vol II · Pt III · Ch 7Tocqueville argues that in most sectors of a democratic economy wages tend slowly upward: workers have some independent resources...
  70. Vol II · Pt III · Ch 8The Roman and aristocratic family was a political unit with the father as its constituted ruler; filial obedience was not merely a...
  71. Vol II · Pt III · Ch 9Tocqueville finds the American treatment of young women striking and unlike anything in Europe. Rather than being kept in...
  72. Vol II · Pt III · Ch 10The paradox Tocqueville records here is real and intentional. American women enjoy greater independence before marriage than women...
  73. Vol II · Pt III · Ch 11Tocqueville pushes back against the easy explanation of American virtue — climate, race, religion — and proposes that equality of...
  74. Vol II · Pt III · Ch 12One of the book's most contested chapters and still one of its most thought-provoking. Tocqueville distinguishes the American...
  75. Vol II · Pt III · Ch 13A counter-intuitive observation: equality does not produce homogeneous sociability. Precisely because all citizens are formally...
  76. Vol II · Pt III · Ch 14A nuanced comparative assessment of what democratic society does to behaviour. Aristocratic manners, Tocqueville argues, are a...
  77. Vol II · Pt III · Ch 15A psychologically precise chapter on the democratic character. Tocqueville explains American gravity as the product of two forces...
  78. Vol II · Pt III · Ch 16Tocqueville contrasts two national vanities, both descended from the same Anglo-Protestant stock but shaped by different social...
  79. Vol II · Pt III · Ch 17One of the most brilliant compressed observations in the book. American society is constantly agitated — fortunes, laws, and...
  80. Vol II · Pt III · Ch 18The longest and most philosophical chapter in Part 3 of Volume II. Tocqueville argues that 'honor' is not a universal moral...
  81. Vol II · Pt III · Ch 19One of Tocqueville's most counterintuitive and enduring observations. The removal of aristocratic barriers should, in theory...
  82. Vol II · Pt III · Ch 20A short comparative chapter on a structural danger that Tocqueville associates more with Europe than with America, though he...
  83. Vol II · Pt III · Ch 21One of the most densely argued and important chapters in Part 4. Tocqueville addresses a paradox: democratic nations seem ripe for...
  84. Vol II · Pt III · Ch 22A structural analysis of the paradox of democratic military culture. The social forces that make democratic nations peaceful...
  85. Vol II · Pt III · Ch 23A short, precise chapter that focuses Tocqueville's earlier analysis on the NCO. Democratic conscript armies contain many soldiers...
  86. Vol II · Pt III · Ch 24Tocqueville explains a structural paradox of democratic military power. At the outset of a campaign, democratic armies are...
  87. Vol II · Pt III · Ch 25A brief but important clarification. The common aristocratic assumption is that democratic armies cannot maintain discipline...
  88. Vol II · Pt III · Ch 26The final military chapter draws together the threads of the preceding analysis into a broad strategic argument. When the...
  89. Vol II · Pt IV · Ch 1This chapter opens Part 4 of Volume II, Tocqueville's most prophetic section. It establishes the fundamental tension: equality...
  90. Vol II · Pt IV · Ch 2An analysis of the intellectual habits equality produces and the political imagination those habits generate. In aristocratic...
  91. Vol II · Pt IV · Ch 3The preceding chapter showed that democratic intellectual habits tend toward centralisation; this one shows that democratic...
  92. Vol II · Pt IV · Ch 4A crucial comparative chapter that explains why America — despite sharing all the general democratic tendencies toward...
  93. Vol II · Pt IV · Ch 5One of the most politically precise chapters in the book. Tocqueville observes a paradox that would have been visible to any...
  94. Vol II · Pt IV · Ch 6The chapter that contains Tocqueville's most famous and most disturbing passage: the picture of the new democratic despotism. It...
  95. Vol II · Pt IV · Ch 7Having spent the preceding chapters diagnosing the danger, Tocqueville turns constructive. He is persuaded that democratic...
  96. Vol II · Pt IV · Ch 8The book's closing chapter is at once a summary and a confession. Tocqueville admits that the society of the modern world has only...

Read Chapter 59 in the reader →