Chapter 12 of 19

The Other Side of the Wall

Sara imagines everything happening on the other side of the wall between the seminary and the Indian gentleman's house. She is more right than she knows.

Summary

Sara is fond of the Indian gentleman in the way she is fond of the Large Family — through observation, from a distance, by imagining the life behind the windows. She has developed, she tells Ermengarde, the habit of adopting people she never speaks to. You can feel quite close to someone, she explains, just by watching them and thinking about them and being sorry for things.

The kitchen servants know more than Sara. They know the Indian gentleman is not really Indian — he is an Englishman who lived in India. They know he came very close to losing everything in a business connected with mines. They know that the fortune was restored after all, but too late to stop the illness that has left him shattered. Sara, listening, works out the parallel: he felt what her father felt. He was ill as her father was ill. He did not die.

She begins to think of him differently — not only as a figure to observe but as a person who would understand certain things if she could speak to him. She imagines him on the other side of the wall between his study and the school's classroom. She does not know what he is thinking about. He is thinking, at this moment, about the missing daughter of a dead friend whose name she would recognize.

All 19 chapters — click to jump
  1. Chapter 1Sara and Captain Crewe arrive at Miss Minchin's seminary through a London fog. She is seven, thoughtful beyond her years, and...
  2. Chapter 2Sara's first morning in the schoolroom. Every pupil watches her; Lavinia takes against her immediately. When Monsieur Dufarge...
  3. Chapter 3Sara and Ermengarde deepen their friendship. Sara explains that knowing French is an accident of birth, not a virtue. She also...
  4. Chapter 4Sara reflects on three years of being Miss Minchin's showpiece pupil and worries that she has never been properly tested. She...
  5. Chapter 5Sara notices Becky the scullery maid peering through the railings, and later raises her voice while telling a story so Becky can...
  6. Chapter 6A letter from Captain Crewe brings news of a diamond-mine investment — a fortune in prospect. Sara turns it into an Arabian Nights...
  7. Chapter 7Sara's eleventh birthday. Miss Minchin has organized a party; the Last Doll has arrived from Paris. Then a letter from India...
  8. Chapter 8The first night in the attic. Sara lies in the dark and says: my papa is dead. In the morning Miss Minchin begins the regime — the...
  9. Chapter 9Sara names the large rat who lives in the attic wall Melchisedec and begins leaving crumbs for him. Lottie visits and asks if Sara...
  10. Chapter 10Sara adopts the sick Indian gentleman next door as a friend she has never spoken to. She also watches the Large Family across the...
  11. Chapter 11Sara watches a sunset from her attic skylight. The Indian gentleman's monkey escapes from the next roof and jumps to her shoulder....
  12. Chapter 12Sara learns that the Indian gentleman is English, was nearly ruined by mines, and survived — unlike her father. She imagines him...
  13. Chapter 13The Bastille game, in full: Sara and Becky huddle under coverlets in the attic and pretend it is a prison cell in revolutionary...
  14. Chapter 14While Sara is out, Ram Dass and Carrisford's secretary climb through the skylight. They examine the attic — bare boards, single...
  15. Chapter 15Sara returns from a winter errand and finds the attic transformed: fire blazing, thick rug, cushions, a meal under a cover, warm...
  16. Chapter 16Ermengarde smuggles a hamper of food up to the attic for a secret feast and finds Sara's room transformed beyond anything she...
  17. Chapter 17The Carmichael children are cheering up Carrisford when Sara appears to return the monkey. He speaks to her. Something in her face...
  18. Chapter 18Mrs. Carmichael explains everything to Sara. Carrisford's solicitor explains the situation to Miss Minchin, who discovers that her...
  19. Chapter 19Sara and Carrisford tell each other their stories. She tells the banquet-and-dream story; he tells the Ram Dass story. The Large...

Read Chapter 12 in the reader →