The Histories a guided tour

Phoenicians abduct Io

The work's famous first sentence announces its purpose: to preserve the great deeds of Greeks and barbarians from oblivion, and to record the cause of their wars. Herodotus immediately gives the floor to the Persians, who trace the quarrel to the Phoenicians. The merchants arrive at Argos selling Egyptian and Assyrian wares; on the fifth or sixth day of trading, a crowd of women — including Io, daughter of the king — comes to the shore. The Phoenicians rush at them and seize Io along with a few others, sailing immediately to Egypt. Herodotus introduces his method from the first line: he is reporting what the Persians say, not asserting what happened.

Europa, Medea, equal wrongs

The Persians continue their account of mutual injuries. Greeks — probably Cretans — sail to Tyre and carry off Europa, balancing Io's abduction. Then a Greek expedition to Colchis on the Phasis river completes its business and takes Medea, the king's daughter. When Colchis sends a herald to Hellas demanding satisfaction, the Greeks refuse — just as the Phoenicians had refused for Io. The tit-for-tat structure is exact and slightly absurd: each side's refusal to make restitution licenses the next offence. Herodotus presents this Persian framework straight-faced, as a serious account of how ancient injuries accumulate into civilisational conflict.

Paris seizes Helen

In the next generation, Alexander (Paris), son of Priam, hears of the mutual abductions and reasons that he too can seize a Greek woman without consequence — after all, no Greek had ever made satisfaction for Medea. He carries off Helen. The Greeks, however, respond very differently this time: they demand her back, with restitution. When the Trojans refuse — throwing the Medea abduction back at them — the Greeks launch the Trojan War. In the Persian telling, this is where Greek behaviour becomes inconsistent and culpable: they refused to give satisfaction for Medea but were willing to go to war over Helen. Herodotus continues to relay the Persian account without endorsing it.

Asia claims its own territory

The Persian account draws its moral conclusion: while both sides had carried off women, only the Greeks had done what truly mattered — crossed into Asia with an army to make war. The Persians argue it is foolish to seek revenge for an abduction, since no woman is taken without her consent. But the Greeks, over a single Spartan woman, sent an army to destroy the kingdom of Priam. From that moment the Persians regarded the Hellenic race as their enemies. They consider Asia and its peoples their own domain; Europe and the Greeks they regard as a separate world. Herodotus marks the structural divide that the rest of the Histories will cross and re-cross.

Herodotus names Croesus

Having summarised both the Persian and Phoenician versions of the Io story — the Phoenicians say she went willingly after becoming pregnant by the ship's captain — Herodotus famously steps back. He refuses to say whether events happened one way or the other. Then he makes his decisive pivot: he will move on from myth to the historical record, treating great and small cities alike, since human prosperity is not fixed in one place. He announces that he knows who first wronged the Greeks within human memory: Croesus of Lydia. The sentence is one of the most important in the book — a declaration that history begins where verifiable knowledge begins.

Croesus, first Greek conqueror

Herodotus introduces Croesus properly: Lydian by race, son of Alyattes, ruler of the nations west of the river Halys. He was the first barbarian, so far as we know, to force tribute on Greek cities — conquering the Ionians, Aeolians, and Dorians of Asia — while forming friendly alliances with the Lacedaemonians on the mainland. The observation that before Croesus all the Greeks had been free sharpens the historical significance of his reign: the Cimmerian raids that preceded him had been plundering expeditions, not conquest. Croesus is the first to turn Greek freedom into subjection, and everything that follows — Persian expansion, Marathon, Thermopylae, Salamis — flows from that precedent.

How the Mermnadae took power

The Mermnadae, Croesus's family, did not always rule Sardis. Before them the Heraclids — descendants of Heracles — held the throne for twenty-two generations, five hundred and five years, passing power from father to son all the way down to Candaules, son of Myrsus. Herodotus provides a careful genealogy from Agron, first of the Heraclids, through Candaules, the last. This digression into dynastic prehistory is characteristic: to understand what Croesus is and where his power comes from, you must understand the lineage he inherited and how it changed hands. The chapter sets up the famous story of Candaules and Gyges, which will explain the transfer of the throne from Heraclids to Mermnadae.

Candaules shows Gyges his queen

Candaules, the last Heraclid king of Sardis, was passionately in love with his own wife and convinced she was the most beautiful woman alive. He shares this conviction obsessively with his favourite guard, Gyges, son of Dascylus. Then he proposes the violation: Gyges must see the queen naked, to confirm with his own eyes what Candaules claims. Gyges protests vigorously — he quotes proverbial wisdom about looking only at one's own — and warns that when a woman removes her tunic she removes her modesty with it. But Candaules insists. The scene is one of the most psychologically vivid in Herodotus: a king whose excess of love becomes a form of blindness that destroys him. His pride in his wife's beauty, displayed to another man, is the first step in the pattern of reversal.

The scheme to spy on the queen

Candaules sweeps aside Gyges's protests and lays out the scheme. After nightfall, Gyges will be placed behind the open door of the royal bedroom. The queen will enter, lay her clothes on a chair near the door, and Gyges can observe her at leisure. When she walks to the bed and turns her back, he must slip out silently. Candaules assures Gyges that no harm will come from the king and that the queen will never know. The detail Herodotus gives the plan — the chair, the sequence, the moment of departure — makes the reader feel the mechanics of voyeurism and the recklessness of Candaules. He has arranged everything, except for what happens next.

The queen sees Gyges

Unable to refuse the king, Gyges agrees and hides in the chamber. The queen enters, undresses, and lays her clothes on the chair as Candaules described. When she turns toward the bed, Gyges moves to the door — but she sees him as he leaves. She grasps at once what has happened: her husband has staged the scene deliberately. Though struck with shame, she makes no outcry and gives no sign. She pretends to have noticed nothing, while inwardly resolving to take her revenge. Among the Lydians, as among many other peoples, it is a disgrace even for a man to be seen naked. The violation of modesty is not just personal — it is a cultural transgression, and the queen's silence is not acceptance. It is the calm before retribution.

Two paths for Gyges

At dawn the queen summons Gyges through her most loyal servants. He comes unsuspecting. She states the situation without preamble: two paths lie open. Either he kills Candaules and takes her and the kingdom of Lydia, or he dies here now, so that he will never again see what he should not. One of the two — Candaules who devised the scheme, or Gyges who looked — must die. Gyges stands astonished and begs to be released from such a choice. But the queen is unmoved. When he sees there is no escape, he chooses to live and asks how the attack should be made. She tells him: from the same place where he stood to look, while the king sleeps.

Gyges kills the king

The execution is swift and almost entirely without description. Gyges cannot leave and has no way out but to kill or be killed. The queen hides him behind the same door — the bedroom door that staged his crime — and gives him a dagger. When Candaules sleeps, Gyges comes upon him secretly and kills him, then takes the queen and the kingdom. Herodotus adds a single external corroboration: the Parian poet Archilochus, who lived around that time, mentioned Gyges in an iambic trimeter verse. The economy of the narrative — the entire coup accomplished in one sentence — is characteristic: Herodotus has built the drama carefully and does not need to dwell on the act itself. The dynastic change is accomplished.

Gyges confirmed by Delphi

The Lydians are angry at Candaules's murder and rise in arms against Gyges. An agreement is reached: if the Delphic oracle pronounces Gyges the rightful king, he keeps the throne; if not, power returns to the Heraclid line. The oracle confirms him — but the Pythian prophetess adds a prophecy that the Heraclids will be avenged on the fifth descendant of Gyges. This prophecy is reported and then immediately dismissed: neither the Lydians nor their kings paid it any attention — until it was fulfilled. The aside is one of Herodotus's most quietly devastating: the oracle's truth is always already there; human beings simply choose not to hear it until it is too late.

Gyges's gifts to Delphi

Gyges begins his reign by sending lavish offerings to Delphi: more silver than any other man, and a vast quantity of gold. His most notable gift is six golden mixing-bowls weighing thirty talents, which stand in the treasury of the Corinthians — though Herodotus carefully notes that this treasury belongs to Cypselus, son of Eëtion, not to the Corinthian state. Gyges is the first barbarian to dedicate offerings at Delphi after Midas, son of Gordias, king of Phrygia, who had given his judgment throne. The Delphians call the gold and silver Gyges dedicated after his name: Gygian. Gyges also leads armies against Miletus and Smyrna, takes the lower town of Colophon, and reigns thirty-eight years — without any other deed worth recording.

Ardys and the Cimmerians

Ardys, son of Gyges, succeeds his father and presses the wars against the Greek cities. He takes Priene and launches a new invasion of Milesian territory. But then a larger disruption arrives from the north: the Cimmerians, a nomadic people driven from their homes by the Scythians, sweep into Asia and capture Sardis — all except the citadel. This is the Cimmerian invasion that Herodotus had earlier distinguished from true conquest: it was a raid that took the lower city but not the heights, and the Mermnadae dynasty survived it. The episode illustrates the perpetual vulnerability of settled wealth to nomadic force — a motif that will return in Cyrus's fatal campaign against the Massagetae.

Sadyattes and Alyattes

The dynastic succession moves quickly. After Ardys's forty-nine-year reign, his son Sadyattes takes power for twelve years, and after him comes Alyattes. Alyattes's reign will prove one of the most eventful — he makes war on Cyaxares and the Medes, finally drives the Cimmerians out of Asia, captures Smyrna (founded originally from Colophon), and launches an invasion against Clazomenae that ends in heavy losses. Herodotus marks this last fact without lingering: from Clazomenae he returned not as he wished, but with heavy losses. The framing signals that more significant deeds follow, and the following chapters will describe the long war against Miletus in detail.

Alyattes's strange siege of Miletus

Alyattes inherits the war against Miletus from his father and pursues it with a distinctive logic. His army marches into Milesian territory each year when the crops are ripe, to the sound of pipes, harps, and both male and female flutes — a detail Herodotus gives with evident relish. When the army arrives, it burns and destroys the crops and trees without touching the farmhouses or outbuildings. The reason: since the Milesians control the sea, a siege is useless. But if the houses stand, the Milesians will replant the fields each year, giving Alyattes something to destroy the following season. The war is run as a system of perpetual economic attrition rather than conquest, and it reveals Alyattes as a ruler who understands the long arithmetic of siege warfare.

Eleven years of crop warfare

Alyattes prosecutes the war for eleven years total, though the first six belong to his father Sadyattes, who had begun it. During those six years it was Sadyattes who invaded Milesian territory each season; the remaining five years are Alyattes's own. In the course of the war the Milesians are twice defeated in pitched battle — once in the district of Limeneium and again on the plain of the Maeander. None of the Ionian Greek cities comes to Miletus's aid except the Chians. They help because the Milesians had earlier helped them in their war against the Erythraeans — a debt of solidarity repaid. The detail is characteristic of Herodotus: he tracks the networks of alliance and obligation that connect Greek cities, even in passing.

The temple fire ends the war

In the twelfth year of the war, the burning crops set fire to the temple of Athena at Assesos in Milesian territory, burning it to the ground. At first no one takes it seriously — it is an accidental consequence of the annual harvest destruction. But Alyattes falls ill soon after, and when the illness persists he sends messengers to consult the Delphic oracle. The Pythian prophetess refuses to answer them at all until the Lydians rebuild the temple of Athena they have burned in Milesian territory. An accidental fire, an unexplained illness, and an oracular refusal combine to force Alyattes into peace negotiations he would not otherwise have undertaken. The oracle intervenes in the war not through prophecy but through a precondition.

Periander tips off Thrasybulus

The Milesians add their own element to the story. Periander, son of Cypselus and tyrant of Corinth, is a close guest-friend of Thrasybulus, tyrant of Miletus. When Periander hears about the oracle that has been given to Alyattes — that he must rebuild the temple before Delphi will speak to him again — he immediately sends a message to Thrasybulus so that his friend can prepare. This is guest-friendship in its most practical form: privileged information passed through personal networks to allow a political ally to manoeuvre. Herodotus attributes this detail to the Milesians specifically, distinguishing it from the Delphian account. He is careful about who claims to know what.

Thrasybulus fakes abundance

Thrasybulus, forewarned by Periander, devises a stratagem. He has all the city's food stores — both public and private — piled in the marketplace, then orders the Milesians to drink and feast together when he gives the signal. His herald will then arrive at a city that appears to be a scene of abundant, carefree celebration. The purpose is to make the Lydian envoy report back to Alyattes that Miletus is prosperous and well-provisioned — completely contradicting whatever image of a starving, exhausted city Alyattes had formed after eleven years of crop destruction. The stratagem turns the herald himself into an instrument of misinformation.

Peace with Miletus

The stratagem works perfectly. The Lydian herald sees the marketplace piled with food and the citizens feasting, delivers Alyattes's truce proposal to Thrasybulus, and returns to Sardis with the opposite of what Alyattes expected to hear. Alyattes had assumed Miletus was near collapse — the herald reports it is prospering. Confronted with this reversal of his assumptions, Alyattes makes peace, not on terms of Lydian dominance but of mutual guest-friendship and alliance. He also builds two temples to Athena at Assesos — double the one he burned — and recovers from his illness. Herodotus closes the episode neatly: the war that eleven years of military pressure could not end was ended by a piece of theatre and a diplomatic obligation.

Arion of Methymna

The mention of Periander licenses a digression. Herodotus identifies him as son of Cypselus and tyrant of Corinth, and notes that during his lifetime an extraordinary marvel occurred: the harpist Arion of Methymna was carried to shore at Taenarum on the back of a dolphin. Arion is identified as the finest harpist of his day and the first man to compose a dithyramb, name it, and teach it to a chorus at Corinth — an attribution that matters for the history of Greek lyric and dramatic poetry. The story of a singer saved by a dolphin is presented as one of the great marvels of Periander's time, corroborated by both Corinthians and Lesbians, and Herodotus will tell it fully in the next chapter.

Arion and the dolphin

Arion, having made his fortune in Italy and Sicily, hires a Corinthian crew to take him home. At sea the sailors plot to throw him overboard and seize his wealth. When Arion learns of the plot, he begs for his life, then offers them his money, but cannot move them. He asks one last thing: to stand on deck in his full minstrel's costume and sing before they kill him. They agree — eager to hear the greatest musician alive. He performs the Orthian strain, then throws himself into the sea in his full costume. A dolphin carries him to Taenarum. He makes his way to Corinth, tells Periander everything, and Periander, skeptical, keeps him under guard while watching for the sailors. When they arrive and deny any knowledge of Arion, he suddenly appears before them. Astonished, they confess. At Taenarum, a small bronze figure of a man on a dolphin's back commemorates the event.

Alyattes's death and offerings

Herodotus closes the account of Alyattes briefly: he died after reigning fifty-seven years. Having recovered from his illness, he dedicated a votive offering at Delphi — the second of his house to do so. The offering is described precisely: a great silver mixing-bowl on an iron stand, the iron welded rather than hammered, making it, Herodotus says, the most remarkable object at Delphi. The stand was made by Glaucus of Chios, whom Herodotus identifies as the first man ever to discover the art of welding iron. The detail is a small technological aside that is characteristic: Herodotus notices inventions and attributes them, preserving knowledge that might otherwise be lost. Alyattes is a significant king — long-reigning, militarily active — but his chapter closes on a craftsman's name.

Croesus attacks the Greek cities

Alyattes dies and his son Croesus succeeds at the age of thirty-five — the man Herodotus has announced from chapter five as the first within human knowledge to wrong the Greeks. Croesus opens his reign by attacking the Ephesians. The Ephesians, besieged, dedicate their city to Artemis by tying a rope from Artemis's temple to the city wall — a gesture of formal supplication to the goddess. The distance between the old city and the temple is seven furlongs. After the Ephesians, Croesus turns to the other Ionian and Aeolian cities one by one, manufacturing complaints against each — serious charges where he can find them, trivial ones where he cannot. The systematic campaign of subjugation is deliberate and methodical.

The wise man stops the fleet

Having subdued the Asian Greeks, Croesus plans to build a fleet and attack the island Greeks. But a wise man — either Bias of Priene or Pittacus of Mytilene, depending on the source — arrives at Sardis and tells him the islanders are hiring ten thousand horsemen to march on Sardis. Croesus, thinking this real, says he hopes the gods give the islanders that idea. The wise man points out the absurdity: Croesus would love to catch islanders fighting on horseback on the mainland — but the islanders are equally hoping to catch the Lydians at sea, where they could take revenge for the subjugated Greeks of Asia. Croesus, pleased at this logic, abandons the shipbuilding and forms a friendship with the island Greeks instead. A single well-aimed quip ends a fleet-building programme.

The extent of Croesus's empire

Herodotus pauses to survey the full extent of Croesus's empire. Nearly all the peoples west of the river Halys have been subdued: Lydians, Phrygians, Mysians, Mariandynians, Chalybes, Paphlagonians, Thynian and Bithynian Thracians, Carians, Ionians, Dorians, Aeolians, and Pamphylians. Only the Cilicians and Lycians remain independent. The list is a roll-call of the peoples of Asia Minor — a vast arc of territories under one king's rule. Herodotus gives the catalogue without commentary, but the effect is cumulative: the magnitude of what Croesus has assembled makes its eventual loss correspondingly catastrophic. The chapter ends mid-sentence, continuing into the next.

Solon arrives at Sardis

As Croesus extends his dominion, all the wise men of Hellas make their way to Sardis, drawn by its wealth and fame. Among them is Solon the Athenian — the great lawgiver who had given Athens its constitution and then voluntarily exiled himself for ten years. He left, Herodotus explains, so that he could not be pressured into repealing his own laws: the Athenians had sworn solemn oaths to live under his laws for ten years, but only Solon's absence could guarantee that oath would not be tested by factions demanding amendments. The detail is important: Solon is a man who has engineered his own displacement to protect a constitutional order. He arrives at Sardis, the wealthiest city in the world, to see what the world looks like.

Count no man happy until he is dead

Croesus shows Solon his treasuries and asks: who is the happiest of all men? He expects to be named. Solon, using no flattery, names Tellus the Athenian. Croesus, astonished, asks why. Solon explains: Tellus lived when his city was prospering, had fine sons, saw grandchildren born and growing up, had what counts for wealth among the Athenians, and died the most glorious death possible — charging into battle at Eleusis, routing the enemy, and falling on the spot. The Athenians buried him publicly with full honours. Croesus, expecting to hear his own name, instead hears that happiness requires a completed life, a prospering city, good children, civic virtue, and a fine death. None of these can be assessed while the man is still alive — which is the whole point of Solon's answer, though Croesus has not yet understood it.

Solon's Second Choice

Solon has named Tellus of Athens as the happiest man he knows, and Croesus, irritated, presses for second place. Solon gives it to Cleobis and Biton, two Argive brothers who, when the oxen failed, harnessed themselves to the cart and dragged their mother to the temple of Hera — a distance of five miles — so she would not miss the festival. The mother prayed that her sons be given the best gift in human power to receive. They lay down in the temple, went to sleep, and never woke. Herodotus delivers the moral with Solon's words: the gods were showing by this that it is better for a man to be dead than to be alive. Croesus is furious. The anecdote is the second panel of the Solon diptych, demonstrating that in Solon's view, and in Herodotus's, complete happiness is only visible in retrospect, at or after death.

Call No Man Happy

Solon lays out the mathematics of a life: seventy years, seventy times three hundred and sixty-five days, not one of which brings the same things as another. Man is wholly accident. No man of great wealth is more happy than a man who lives well day to day unless fortune keeps smiling on him until death — for great wealth brings great power to suffer, while a man of moderate means needs only small goods to keep going. The richest man has two advantages over the day-labourer: the power to satisfy his desires and to absorb a blow from fortune. Solon advises Croesus to look to the end, for many whom God shows prosperity at the beginning he overturns at the end. Croesus dismisses Solon as a fool who ignores the evidence of present goods. The scene closes on the most consequential dismissal in the first book.

Solon Dismissed

Herodotus closes the Solon episode in a single brief chapter: Croesus dismissed Solon as worthless, thinking him entirely senseless for ignoring present prosperity and bidding men look to the end. Solon departs and immediately after his going, retribution from God came upon Croesus greatly, because he reckoned himself to be the most prosperous of men. Herodotus is explicit that the divine retribution is connected to Croesus's self-satisfaction. The sentence is one of the most efficient in the Histories: Solon leaves, and God moves. The rest of Book 1, from this chapter forward, is the unrolling of what that retribution looks like in practice — the death of his son, the fall of his kingdom, the pyre on which he calls Solon's name. The chapter is less than fifty words in the Greek but it does the narrative work of a hinge.

The Dream of the Spear

The divine retribution begins with a dream. Croesus sees his son Atys struck down by an iron spear. Croesus, who has another son, deaf and mute, but regards Atys as the only one who counts, immediately acts: he takes all the iron weapons from the walls of the palace, stacks them in the women's quarters so they cannot accidentally wound his son, and forbids Atys from joining any military expedition. The chapter is a compressed illustration of the tragic logic Herodotus is setting up: the knowledge of a prophecy combined with imperfect action to avoid it. Croesus takes the dream seriously — more seriously than he took Solon's warning — but the action he takes cannot encompass every iron object in the world. The chapter introduces the Phrygian exile Adrastos, whose name in Greek means 'unable to flee,' a detail Herodotus probably knows will not escape his audience.

The Exile Adrastos

Adrastos is the second protagonist of the tragedy that Herodotus is assembling. He is a Phrygian of royal descent who has accidentally killed his brother and, after the purification ritual Greek law required, has made his way to Sardis to beg Croesus's hospitality. Croesus purifies him and takes him in. Adrastos is the instrument of the divine retribution that is coming, though neither he nor Croesus knows this. Herodotus presents him without dramatic irony in the authorial voice — the irony is structural, carried by the name and the setup. The chapter illustrates a consistent feature of Herodotus's storytelling: the instrument of a man's doom often arrives as a suppliant needing help, which the great man provides generously. Helping Adrastos is, on every rational calculus, the right thing for Croesus to do; it is also the action that guarantees his ruin.

The Mysian Boar

At this point in the narrative, the plot thickens through a new element: a prodigious boar appears on Mount Olympus in Mysia, ranging down to destroy the farmland below. The Mysians cannot kill it on their own and send to Croesus to ask him for men and hounds. Croesus agrees to send the hunting party but without his son, since he is keeping Atys confined to the palace out of fear of the dream. The chapter introduces the mechanism by which Atys will be freed and placed in the path of danger: the hunt. Herodotus has assembled all the pieces of the tragedy and is now setting them in motion through the logic of a reasonable chain of events — a boar, a request, a generous king, a young man who feels insulted by being kept at home — rather than through divine compulsion.

Atys Pleads His Case

Atys hears about the Mysian boar hunt and is stung by his exclusion. He goes to his father and makes an argument that is, by every rational standard, correct: a boar has no hands, no iron spear; the dream warned of death by an iron point; therefore hunting a boar poses no danger from that specific quarter. He frames his case as a matter of honor — his new wife will think he is a coward if he is kept home from every military or hunting expedition. Herodotus gives Atys a speech of moderate length that is structurally important: the young man's reasoning is perfectly logical within the information he has. He cannot know that Adrastos, whom his father intends to send along as guardian, is the instrument of the very death the dream foretold. This is one of Herodotus's repeated demonstrations that rational precaution is no guarantee against what the gods have arranged.

The Father's Concession

Croesus responds to Atys's argument by explaining why he has been confined. He tells the dream openly — something he had apparently not done before — and admits that he, Croesus, has been trying to protect his most beloved son from the fate it seemed to foretell. But he concedes Atys's point about the boar: it has no hands. He gives his son permission to go to the hunt, but as a concession between a father's fear and a son's argument, not as a full release from anxiety. The chapter shows Croesus behaving as a reasonable, loving father would: he shares the information behind his protection, he hears the counter-argument, he yields to the part of it that is logically compelling. His decision is the right one given what he knows. The gap between what he knows and what the gods have arranged is the gap into which Atys will fall.

The Son's Argument Wins

Atys receives his father's partial permission and responds with a brief acknowledgment: the logic about iron and boars was the decisive point, and he is grateful for the concession. The dialogue between father and son is now closed, and the plot mechanism is in place. Herodotus moves the chapter quickly; the purpose is to confirm that the exchange has resolved and Atys will go. What the chapter adds is a small emotional note — Atys accepts not triumphantly but with something like understanding of his father's fear, and with gratitude for being listened to. The narrative is building toward the hunt and Herodotus does not linger. The chapter is one of the shorter ones in the Croesus sequence, functioning as a bridge between the persuasion and the catastrophe.

Adrastos Appointed Guardian

Having given his son permission, Croesus now takes what he believes is the decisive precaution: he summons Adrastos and asks him, in the name of the guest-friendship Croesus has shown him, to accompany Atys on the hunt and act as his guardian. The speech is a reminder of the hospitality debt — Croesus purified this man, took him in, supports him at court — and the request is calibrated as an obligation of honor rather than merely a request. Adrastos cannot well refuse. Croesus believes he is hedging against the dream by sending a trusted fighter alongside his son. He does not know that Adrastos is the instrument the dream was pointing to. The scene is Herodotus at his most technically accomplished: every action follows from good motives and careful reasoning, every action advances inexorably toward the catastrophe.

Adrastos's Dark Reluctance

Adrastos does not simply accept. He says something that, under any ordinary circumstances, would be cause for Croesus to change his mind: he confesses that he does not think himself a fit companion for a man he is supposed to protect, that a man who has suffered as he has does not bring good fortune, that he would rather not go on any contest of valour. He is saying, as clearly as a man can say it without naming what cannot be named, that he is marked. Croesus overrules the objection: Adrastos has done no deliberate wrong, the misfortune was involuntary, it is not his fault, and Croesus himself orders him to go. The scene is one of the most quietly devastating moments in the Histories — the instrument of doom is given a speaking moment in which he almost prevents the catastrophe, and the well-meaning king eliminates the last obstacle.

The Fatal Agreement

The agreement is sealed and the party departs for Mount Olympus in Mysia. The chapter is brief — a sentence or two — and functions as the hinge between negotiation and event. Herodotus moves quickly here; he has spent six chapters on the preparation and now allows only a moment before the outcome. The speed of the transition from debate to catastrophe mirrors the nature of the event: carefully deliberated tragedy arrives without ceremony. The chapter ends with the hunt underway, the hunters on the mountain tracking the boar, and the reader already knowing from the mechanics of what Herodotus has assembled that Atys will not return. The dramatic irony is complete.

The Spear Flies

The hunters track the boar to a clearing on the mountain. The hunt reaches its climax. Adrastos throws his spear at the boar, misses, and hits Atys. The dream is fulfilled. Herodotus tells the death in a single sentence. There is no extended scene of dying, no last words, no theatrical prolongation. Atys is struck by the iron spearhead — the very weapon Croesus had been protecting him from by removing iron from the palace walls — and dies. Adrastos the Phrygian, unable to flee his fate as his name foretold, has done it again: killed the person he was obligated to protect, involuntarily, with a weapon meant for something else. The chapter is one of the great demonstrations of Herodotean economy — six chapters of preparation, one sentence of event.

Adrastos and the Pyre

The Lydians carry the corpse of Atys back to Sardis and Adrastos walks behind it, hands outstretched, asking Croesus to kill him over the body. He says there is no life for him to live having destroyed his host's son after his host destroyed his previous guilt. Croesus's reaction is one of the most discussed in the Histories: he does not blame Adrastos. He speaks of divine will, the dream he had been given, and says that Adrastos is not responsible. When the funeral is complete and everyone else has gone, Adrastos kills himself on the tomb. He is, Herodotus says, the most ill-fated of all men he knew. The chapter closes the Croesus family tragedy with a strange grace: the bereaved father forgives the killer, and the killer, unable to live with himself, resolves the impossibility of his situation by his own hand.

Croesus Consults Oracles

After two years of mourning for Atys, Croesus receives news that shakes him out of grief and into political anxiety: Cyrus has overthrown the Median king Astyages. This development brings the Persian power directly to the border of Lydia. Croesus decides he must act, and his first action — characteristically Herodotean — is epistemological. Before doing anything, he wants to know whether the oracles are reliable. He sends envoys simultaneously to several oracles around the Greek world: Delphi, Dodona, Amphiaraos, Trophonius, Branchidae of Miletus, and two others. The envoys are given identical instructions: go on a fixed day, and on the hundredth day after leaving Sardis, ask the oracle what Croesus, king of Lydia, is doing at that exact moment. The answer that matches what Croesus is actually doing will identify the oracle worth trusting.

Delphi Answers Correctly

Herodotus tells us what Croesus was doing on the hundredth day: he was in his palace boiling a tortoise and a lamb together in a bronze cauldron with a bronze lid — a combination so strange and specific that no oracle could guess it by reasoning. The Delphic Pythia, however, gave the correct answer in hexameter verse: I count the grains of sand and measure the sea; I understand the dumb and hear what is never spoken. The smell reaches me of a hard-shelled tortoise boiled in bronze with the flesh of a lamb, where bronze is the floor and bronze the covering. When the Lydian messengers arrived with this answer, Croesus wept and accepted that Delphi alone had found the truth. The test is one of the most famous episodes in the Histories, and Herodotus reports it straightforwardly as a fact — he does not doubt it occurred.

The Oracle of Amphiaraos

Of the other oracles Croesus tested, only the oracle of Amphiaraos at Thebes also gave a correct answer. Herodotus says he cannot tell us what that answer was, because the temple's custom was not to record or repeat the oracular response to outsiders and he has not been able to verify it from any source he trusts. The chapter is a small but important window into Herodotus's method: he is willing to report what he knows, equally willing to admit what he does not know, and unwilling to fill the gap with speculation or hearsay. It is also evidence that his curiosity was practical — he actually tried to find out and failed. The double result, Delphi and Amphiaraos, doubles Croesus's confidence and sets up the enormous sacrificial offerings and questions to come.

The Gift Sacrifices

Confirmed that Delphi and Amphiaraos are reliable, Croesus overwhelms both with offerings. At Delphi he sacrifices three thousand animals of every type that is proper to sacrifice — a number Herodotus gives as a specific record, not a rhetorical flourish. He has bonfires made of costly furniture: golden and silver couches, golden cups, purple robes. He wants the gods to feel the full weight of his gratitude and his wealth. The offerings to Amphiaraos are comparable. The purpose is dual: thanksgiving for passing the test, and the purchase of continued divine favour before asking the most important question of his reign — whether to attack Persia. Herodotus renders the scale of Croesus's offering without irony. The king's generosity is genuine; the gods, or Delphi, will shortly return an oracle that he spectacularly misreads.

The Golden Gifts to Delphi

Herodotus catalogs the physical gifts Croesus sent to Delphi with the detail of someone who had seen the objects himself — which he probably had. A golden lion weighing ten talents sat atop a pyramid of pure gold ingots. Two enormous mixing bowls, one gold and one silver, placed at the entrance to the temple. Four silver casks. Two aspersoria. These objects were the physical record of Lydian wealth and devotion, visible at Delphi for over a century after Croesus's fall. Herodotus notes where they were still to be seen in his own day and records the stories Delphic priests told about whether particular items were Lydian or Delphian in origin. The catalog functions simultaneously as eyewitness evidence, a demonstration of Croesus's character, and a marker of the stakes of the political question he is about to ask.

The Shield of Amphiaraos

Alongside the gifts to Delphi, Croesus sent dedicated objects to the sanctuary of Amphiaraos at Oropus. These included a shield made entirely of gold and a spear with shaft and head both of solid gold. Herodotus says these objects were still in the temple of Ismenian Apollo at Thebes in his day — he has seen them or received reliable reports. The duplication of offerings is consistent with Croesus's character: the king does not simply satisfy the minimum. Both oracles that passed his test receive their full reward. The chapter is brief but part of the larger movement of physical evidence that Herodotus uses to anchor his accounts of the distant past. The objects are proof that the events occurred.

The Critical Question

The thank-offerings made, Croesus now asks the question he has been building toward: should he make war against the Persians, and if so, should he seek a military ally? The envoys bring the question and the oracle's famous ambiguous reply. Herodotus records the exact language the Pythia is reported to have given: if Croesus crosses the Halys river and attacks, he will destroy a great empire. And there is a second element to the oracle: Croesus is advised to seek out the most powerful Greek city and make it his ally. Both pieces of the reply are, in retrospect, technically accurate and immediately misleading. The great empire that will be destroyed is Croesus's own. The ally he will seek is Sparta — a fact that will matter later in the narrative.

The Oracle Received

The oracular answers are brought back to Sardis and Croesus hears them with delight. He is certain he will destroy the Persian empire. He sends further gifts to Delphi — this time a present of two gold staters for every Delphian — and asks whether his reign will last long. The Pythia answers that when a mule becomes king of the Medes, then and only then should the tender-footed Lydian flee. Croesus hears this and takes it as confirmation of permanent safety: no mule will ever rule the Medes. He cannot know that Cyrus the Great, whom he is planning to attack, is himself the product of a mixed union — his father was a Persian, his mother a Median princess. The mule is a metaphor, not a zoological prediction. The chapter is a perfect double-oracle trap: one answer that seems favorable, one that seems impossible, both pointing toward the same disaster.

Third Consultation at Delphi

Having received two favorable oracles, Croesus goes back to Delphi a third time. His confidence in the oracle, founded on the tortoise test, has become a resource he draws on repeatedly. He is now essentially in an ongoing consultation. Herodotus notes that from the moment Croesus verified Delphi's truthfulness, he used it constantly. The third consultation asks about the permanence of his dynasty. He has already received one answer about the mule; now he is layering additional reassurances. The chapter illustrates both Croesus's piety and his selective hearing — he is accumulating oracle-content that confirms his plans and not attending carefully to any of it. The pattern of repeated consultation is a version of the 'triple sure' habit that arises from anxiety rather than confidence.

The Mule Oracle's True Meaning

Herodotus steps briefly outside the narrative to explain the mule oracle to his reader. The mule referred to Cyrus: his father Cambyses was a Persian of good family but without royal blood, while his mother was Mandane, daughter of the Median king Astyages. By Greek metaphorical usage, such a mixed-race offspring could be called a mule — a hybrid of two different breeds. Croesus could not have known this. The oracle was correct and was, in a different sense, clear — but not clear to Croesus, who interpreted 'mule' as a literal impossibility rather than a figurative description of the man who was already king of Persia. The chapter is Herodotus being didactic with his reader in a way he almost never is with his characters: he explains the metaphor so the reader, unlike Croesus, can appreciate the precision of divine speech.

Greeks and Pelasgians

Croesus, advised by the oracle to seek the most powerful Greek ally, surveys the Greek world and finds Athens and Sparta pre-eminent. Herodotus uses this as an occasion for a substantial digression on the origins and character of the Greek-speaking peoples. He distinguishes the Greeks (Hellenes) from the Pelasgians, an older population he cannot confidently locate but associates with pre-Greek Aegean settlements. His claim: the Greeks have always used the same language since they first separated from the Pelasgians as a small and feeble people, and have since spread widely. The Pelasgians, wherever they survive, still speak a non-Greek language. The digression is a piece of proto-linguistic anthropology — the earliest sustained attempt in European literature to use language distribution as evidence for population history.

The Nature of the Hellenes

The ethnographic digression continues. Herodotus argues that the Greek-speaking peoples began as a small and feeble group that grew over time, absorbing some peoples and being absorbed by others. He traces their movements through Thessaly, Histiaeotis, Phthiotis, and eventually into the broader Greek peninsula. The process he describes is one of gradual cultural and linguistic expansion rather than a single migration event, which is broadly consistent with modern archaeological understanding of how Greek-speaking culture spread through the Aegean. The chapter is notable for Herodotus's willingness to speculate about processes he cannot directly observe and for his use of currently visible language distribution as evidence. He is working out the methodology of historical anthropology as he goes.

Croesus Eyes Athens

Croesus's survey of the most powerful Greek city reaches Athens, where he finds that the city is held down and torn with faction by Peisistratos, son of Hippocrates, who rules as tyrant. Herodotus records the story of how Peisistratos came to power in Athens — a story that illustrates the instability of Athenian politics in the mid-sixth century and the nature of Greek tyranny. He begins with a prodigy: when Hippocrates, Peisistratos's father, was present at the Olympic games, a vessel of water boiled without fire being applied to it. The Spartan Chilon told him to have no son, or if he had one already, to disown him and have no dealings with him. Hippocrates ignored the advice. The digression introduces Athens and its complicated political world just as Croesus is deciding which Greek city to approach.

Peisistratos Takes Power

Herodotus tells the story of Peisistratos's first and second tyrannies over Athens in detail. Having won favor through military success against Megara, he persuaded the Athenian assembly to give him a bodyguard of club-bearers and used them to seize the Acropolis. He was expelled by a coalition of the rival factions of Megacles (the Alcmaeonids) and Lycurgus. The two factions then made a deal: Megacles offered Peisistratos the tyranny back in exchange for marrying his daughter. Peisistratos agreed, and then returned to Athens in a procession in which a tall and beautiful woman named Phye, dressed in armor and presented as the goddess Athena herself, rode with him in a chariot. Heralds preceded them announcing that Athena was bringing Peisistratos home. The Athenians, who Herodotus says should have known better than anyone that the gods did not appear this way, believed it.

The Second Tyranny Lost

Having been restored to Athens by the Athena-Phye ruse and the agreement with Megacles, Peisistratos marries Megacles's daughter as agreed. But he already has grown sons and does not want more. Herodotus says he was unwilling to have children with the new wife, and the manner in which he approached her — Herodotus uses the Greek phrase that he 'had intercourse with her not in the customary way' — was discovered by the wife, reported to her mother, and the scandal brought to Megacles. The Alcmaeonid family, outraged at the insult to their daughter, allied again with Lycurgus and expelled Peisistratos for the second time. He went into exile for ten years before assembling the resources for his third and final return. The episode gives Athens its faction-ridden character that Croesus observes and that leads him to prefer Sparta as an ally.

Peisistratos and the Curse

So Peisistratos received the despotism back in the manner described and took Megacles's daughter to wife as agreed. But he already had sons who were young men, and the house of the Alcmaeonidae was said to labor under a curse. Not wishing to have children by her, he approached the marriage unnaturally. His new wife noticed, and either because the matter distressed her or because Megacles asked what was happening, she revealed to her mother what Peisistratos was doing. The mother told Megacles. He, enraged at the insult to his house, immediately reconciled with his former adversaries. Peisistratos, when he heard what was happening against him, left the country entirely. He returned to Greece, gathered money at Rhaikelos in Macedonia, made himself rich there, and after that hired himself to Eretria and after ten years came back to Attica for his third and final seizure of the city.

book-i-clio-chapter-62

book-i-clio-chapter-63

book-i-clio-chapter-64

book-i-clio-chapter-65

book-i-clio-chapter-66

book-i-clio-chapter-67

book-i-clio-chapter-68

book-i-clio-chapter-69

book-i-clio-chapter-70

book-i-clio-chapter-71

book-i-clio-chapter-72

book-i-clio-chapter-73

book-i-clio-chapter-74

book-i-clio-chapter-75

book-i-clio-chapter-76

book-i-clio-chapter-77

book-i-clio-chapter-78

book-i-clio-chapter-79

book-i-clio-chapter-80

book-i-clio-chapter-81

book-i-clio-chapter-82

book-i-clio-chapter-83

book-i-clio-chapter-84

book-i-clio-chapter-85

book-i-clio-chapter-86

book-i-clio-chapter-87

book-i-clio-chapter-88

book-i-clio-chapter-89

book-i-clio-chapter-90

book-i-clio-chapter-91

Apollo's ambiguous reply

Chapter 91 reports the Lydian embassy's return to Delphi after the fall of Sardis. The Lydians blame Apollo for misleading their king. The Pythia answers firmly: the oracle told truth. Croesus asked whether he should attack Persia, and was told that if he did he would destroy a great empire. He failed to ask which empire. The god offered a second chance — the riddle of the mule-king — and Croesus again failed to understand. The oracle was not false; Croesus was not wise enough to read it. The chapter is Herodotus's most sustained meditation on how divine speech works: not deceptive, but demanding a calibre of interpretation that few humans achieve. It is also the formal close of the Croesus narrative and the pivot toward the story of Cyrus.

Croesus's surviving offerings

Chapter 92 is an inventory: the golden lion, the golden mixing-bowls, the silver mixing-vessel, the statues of women in gold, the amber and gold necklaces, and many other objects Croesus deposited at Delphi and at the Theban temple of Apollo Ismenios, along with lesser gifts at Ephesus and Didyma. Herodotus cross-references these objects against inscriptions and visible dedications in his own time, giving the passage a documentary authority that distinguishes it from the narrative chapters around it. The inventory also serves a thematic purpose: these are the objects that survived the fall of Sardis, that outlasted the king who commissioned them, that now stand as the most durable trace of Lydian power. The Histories is, among other things, a book about what human deeds leave behind.

What Lydia left behind

Chapter 93 is Herodotus's ethnographic summary of Lydia before he moves on to Persia. He notes that the Lydians have few customs worth recording except those they share with Greeks — they were, in many respects, culturally close to the Ionian Greeks they had absorbed. One exception stands: the practice of Lydian girls earning their dowries by prostitution before marriage. And one monument stands above all others: the tomb of Alyattes, father of Croesus, a massive mound on the Gygaean Lake built jointly by merchants, craftsmen, and the working girls of Sardis. Herodotus has measured it. It is surpassed, he says, only by the works of Egypt and Babylon. The chapter demonstrates his method of ethnographic closure: before leaving a people, he summarizes their customs and their monuments.

Lydia's claimed Etruscan colony

Chapter 94 presents the Lydian tradition of their own origins: that during a severe famine lasting eighteen years, the king divided the population in two, drew lots, and sent half — under his son Tyrrhenus — to find new land. They sailed west and eventually settled in Italy, calling themselves Tyrsenoi after their leader. This is the Lydian account; the Lydians' neighbors the Xanthians say Lydia was never called Lydia but Maeionia. Herodotus reports both versions without adjudicating. The chapter is a reminder of how much ancient ethnography consisted of origin stories that connected known peoples to one another — the Etruscans in Italy, here traced back to Asia Minor. Modern scholarship has rejected the Lydian-Etruscan connection on genetic and linguistic grounds, but the story Herodotus records is itself a historical fact about how the ancient Mediterranean understood migration and kinship.

Who Cyrus really was

Chapter 95 is the pivot from Lydia to Persia. Herodotus announces his subject — the Persians — and immediately confronts the problem of competing sources. He knows four different accounts of Cyrus's origin and chooses to tell the most credible-seeming one, following his usual practice of recording the source and noting alternatives. The account he selects is the one given by Persians who do not want to aggrandize Cyrus beyond the truth — a phrasing that positions it as the sober version. He then begins the story of Astyages, king of the Medes, and the first of the dreams that will produce the overthrow of Media and the birth of the Persian Empire. The chapter establishes the historiographical stance Herodotus will maintain: he knows more than one version, he selects on grounds of credibility, and he names his source.

The vine that covered Asia

Chapter 96 continues the story of Astyages and the dreams that will produce the fall of Media. Mandane is now married to the Persian Cambyses and pregnant. Astyages has a second dream: a vine grows from his daughter's body and spreads until it covers all of Asia. He consults the Magi again. They interpret the dream as meaning that his daughter's son will rule in his place. Astyages sends for Mandane, by now heavily pregnant, intending to kill the child when it is born. He entrusts this commission to his most trusted official, Harpagus, who will play a central role in the events that follow. The chapter establishes the full apparatus of the fulfilled prophecy: the dream, the interpretation, the attempt to prevent it, and the chain of human decisions that will ensure it comes to pass anyway.

Exposed infant, shepherd's mercy

Chapter 97 is one of the Histories' great narrative passages: the classic exposed-infant story, told with Herodotean precision about motivation. Harpagus delivers the baby to the shepherd Mitradates with instructions to leave it in the mountains to die. Mitradates goes home and finds his wife has just delivered a stillborn son. The two parents, moved partly by pity and partly by the opportunity before them, substitute the dead child for the living one, dress the living child in the dead infant's clothes, and expose the corpse in the mountains. When Harpagus's men come to verify the child is dead, they see the body and report success. The substitution is complete. Cyrus is alive, raised as a shepherd's son. The narrative captures the whole mechanism of prophecy-fulfillment in Herodotus: the gods do not intervene directly; human emotion and human calculation create the gap through which the future arrives.

Boy-king of the playground

Chapter 98 covers Cyrus's childhood revelation. Growing up as a shepherd's son, at about age ten, Cyrus is chosen by the village boys to play the role of king in their games. He governs the game decisively, and when one of the boys — the son of a Mede named Artembares, a man of rank — refuses to obey a directive from the boy-king, Cyrus has him seized and flogged. Artembares's son runs home and complains to his father. Artembares brings the complaint before Astyages: a slave's child has flogged a free Mede's son. Astyages summons both the herdsman and the boy. When he sees Cyrus, something about the child's bearing and features arrests him. He questions Mitradates and, under pressure, Mitradates confesses the substitution. The prophecy Astyages thought he had neutralized is back.

Dream fulfilled in children's play

Chapter 99 shows Astyages in the grip of wishful interpretation. After Mitradates confesses and Cyrus's identity is confirmed, Astyages summons the Magi again. He asks whether the old dream has been fulfilled. The Magi reason that the prophecy said Mandane's son would be king; Cyrus has just played king among the village children; the lesser fulfillment has discharged the prophetic obligation and the grander danger has passed. Astyages accepts this interpretation because he is frightened and wants it to be true. He punishes Harpagus — severely, and by a method Herodotus will describe in the following chapter — and he sends Cyrus back to Persia, to his true parents Cambyses and Mandane. The chapter is a study in how power corrupts the capacity for honest inquiry: Astyages's court tells him what he wants to hear, and Astyages chooses to believe it.

A feast of terrible revenge

Chapter 100 contains one of the most disturbing episodes in the Histories. Astyages, having discovered that Harpagus delegated the killing of Cyrus to a shepherd rather than doing it himself, devises a punishment of mythological savagery. He invites Harpagus to a feast, seats him beside other guests, and serves him dishes made from his son's flesh — all except the head and hands, which are kept separate in a covered basket. After Harpagus has eaten, Astyages asks whether he enjoyed the meal. Harpagus says he is pleased. Astyages uncovers the basket. Harpagus, confronted with his son's remains, does not break down — Herodotus notes this carefully — but says that whatever pleases the king is pleasing to him. The composure with which he receives this horror is, Herodotus implies, the composure of a man storing a grievance for the long term.

Who the Medes were

Chapter 101 is a short ethnographic insert: Herodotus names the six tribes of the Medes — the Busai, Paretakenoi, Strouchates, Arizantoi, Boudioi, and Magi. The Magi are identified as one of the tribes, not merely a priestly caste, which aligns with the picture in the Histories of the Magi as a hereditary Median group with both priestly and political functions. The insert follows Herodotus's consistent practice of pausing at the ethnographic threshold — before a people is conquered or overthrown, he notes who they are. The Medes are about to be overturned by Cyrus; this brief catalog is their memorial.

Wisdom as path to tyranny

Chapter 102 is one of Herodotus's most politically acute passages. The Mede Deioces cultivates a reputation for settling disputes justly among his neighbors. As his fame spreads, more and more Medes bring their disputes to him. He then withdraws his services — he has too much private business to neglect for public work, he says — and the Medes, discovering that injustice fills the vacuum, debate what to do. They decide to elect a king and choose Deioces. Once elected, Deioces requires that they build him a great palace, furnish him with bodyguards, and never approach him directly — all business to be conducted through intermediaries. He withdraws from visibility completely. The passage is the Histories' founding account of political authority: justice is the bait by which power is first accumulated, and the distance of the king from ordinary life is the first act of power consolidated.

Median ambition, Assyrian walls

Chapter 103 follows the rise and fall of Phraortes, son of Deioces. Phraortes first subdues the Persians — already a considerable feat — and then, emboldened, attacks Nineveh and the Assyrian empire. The Assyrians, though their empire is decaying and their former subject peoples are in revolt, still hold their core territory. Their army defeats Phraortes in a major battle and kills him with a large part of his force. Herodotus puts the length of his reign at twenty-two years. The Phraortes episode is an intermediate step in the pattern: Media grows under Deioces, overreaches under Phraortes, and must regroup. The recovery will come under Cyaxares, Phraortes's son, who will succeed where his father failed and destroy Nineveh.

Nomads rule for twenty-eight years

Chapter 104 covers one of the strangest interludes in ancient history: the Scythian occupation of western Asia. After the Median defeat at Nineveh, the Scythians — a nomadic people from the steppes north of the Black Sea — pour into Media and from there across the whole of the Near East. Herodotus says they dominated Asia for twenty-eight years and collected tribute from Egypt (Pharaoh Psammetichus bought them off at the border). The Scythian domination is eventually ended when the Median king Cyaxares invites the Scythian leaders to a feast, gets them drunk, and kills them. The remaining Scythians then withdraw. The episode is important partly as background for Herodotus's extended account of Scythia in Book 4, but also as a reminder that the familiar story of Persian-Greek antagonism was preceded by centuries of Near Eastern volatility and migration that shaped the geopolitical landscape Cyrus inherited.

Raiders, plague, and the goddess

Chapter 105 is a brief but striking digression within the Scythian interlude. During their domination of Asia, a detachment of Scythians sack the sanctuary of Aphrodite Ourania at Ashkelon in Philistia, the oldest sanctuary of that goddess in the world, Herodotus says — the Cyprian and Cytherian sanctuaries are derived from it. Those who plundered the temple were punished with what Herodotus calls the female disease — an effeminacy that afflicted them and their descendants and was still visible, he says, among the Scythians he knew. The passage combines ethnographic observation, religious explanation, and a claim about consequences that extend across generations. It is one of Herodotus's clearest examples of how he uses religious causation alongside political causation: the fate of the Scythians at Ashkelon is a parallel to the fate of Croesus — impiety brings divine punishment.

From horde to disciplined force

Chapter 106 is a short military-history note. Cyaxares, having rid himself of the Scythians by the banquet massacre, reorganizes the Median army. Previously the Medes had fought in an undifferentiated mass; Cyaxares divides the force by weapon: spearmen, archers, and cavalrymen are separated into distinct units. Herodotus says this was the first such organization in Asia. Whether the claim is accurate by modern standards of military history is uncertain, but within the Histories the note functions as a marker of Median institutional progress — Cyaxares is not just recovering from Scythian domination but building a more capable instrument of war. This instrument will shortly be turned against Nineveh, completing the campaign Phraortes had failed.

The vine dream returns

Chapter 107 is the formal re-entry into the Cyrus narrative after the long Scythian and Median military digressions. Cyaxares is succeeded by his son Astyages. Astyages has a daughter, Mandane, and he dreams that from her body flows such a torrent of water that it floods the whole of Asia. He consults the Magi; they interpret it as meaning that his daughter's descendants will rule in his place. He therefore marries Mandane not to any Mede of rank — which would produce an ambitious son-in-law — but to a Persian named Cambyses, a man of good family but modest station. The chapter is in a sense a repetition: the same dream, the same consultation, the same dynastic marriage strategy. Herodotus uses the repetition deliberately — the second dream will be even more explicit, and the attempt to neutralize the prophecy will fail more completely.

A vine that covers Asia

Chapter 108 gives Astyages the second and clearer of his prophetic dreams. Mandane is now married to Cambyses and pregnant with her first child. Astyages dreams that a vine grows from her body and spreads until it overshadows all of Asia. He summons the Magi again. Their interpretation is clearer than before: her son will reign in Astyages's place. This time Astyages does not try another dynastic solution. He summons Mandane back to Media while she is still pregnant and resolves that the child, when born, must die. The chapter makes explicit the mechanism that will produce the plot: Astyages's well-grounded fear, acting through the chain of delegation that leads from Harpagus to the shepherd Mitradates, is what will ensure the prophecy's fulfillment.

The delegate's hesitation

Chapter 109 follows the chain of delegation that will save Cyrus. Harpagus is the man Astyages trusts most. When Astyages gives him the infant and orders him to take it home and kill it, Harpagus thinks carefully. He refuses to do the killing himself for two reasons: first, such a crime against the king's own blood would be impious; second — and more practically — if Astyages should die without a male heir and Mandane became queen, Harpagus would be destroyed. So he summons a royal herdsman named Mitradates and delegates the order to him. The chapter is a study in how political calculation and moral reluctance combine to produce the exact opposite of the intended outcome. Harpagus does not spare Cyrus out of pity; he spares him by delegation, for reasons of self-interest. The irony is that his self-interest will cost him his son.

Two infants, one surviving

Chapter 110 is the domestic heart of the birth narrative. Mitradates brings the infant home and tells his wife, Spako, what has been ordered. She has just given birth to a stillborn son. The situation is immediately clear to her: she asks to see the child Harpagus has sent. She finds it beautifully dressed and attended by gold ornaments, as befits a member of the royal family. She refuses to let it be exposed and presses her husband until he agrees. The plan they form is simple and elegant: dress the living royal child in the dead shepherd's infant's clothes and expose the dead child in the royal ornaments. When Harpagus's men come to check, they will find a dead infant in the circumstances of royalty and report the job done. Herodotus does not sentimentalize the scene; Spako is practical, not heroic. But her practicality is what saves Cyrus.

Shepherd's son, king's blood

Chapter 111 covers the first years of Cyrus's life in the herdsman's household. Harpagus's inspectors find a dead infant in the mountains — the shepherd's son, exposed in royal clothes — and report back that the order has been carried out. Harpagus is satisfied and holds a formal burial for the child (the shepherd's son, though no one except the shepherd and his wife know this). The living child is raised by Mitradates and Spako as their own, given the name Cyrus. Herodotus notes that the name had special resonance in Persia but declines to etymologize it at length. The chapter is the closing of the first narrative arc: the plot to kill Cyrus has officially succeeded in everyone's records except the shepherd's family, and Cyrus is growing up in the hills south of Ecbatana, unaware of his origins.

Natural authority at ten

Chapter 112 describes the games through which Cyrus's nature reveals itself. At about ten years old, Cyrus and the other boys of the village play kingship games in the road, and the boys always choose Cyrus to be king. He assigns them roles: some are his bodyguards, some his builders, one is his eye (the official who reports to the king on what is happening in the kingdom). One boy — Artembares's son — is assigned a task and refuses to do it, or does it poorly. Cyrus orders the others to seize and flog him. The beating is carried out. The boy goes home and reports it to his father as an insult from a slave-born child, which is what he believes Cyrus to be. The complaint sets off the sequence that will lead to Astyages's discovery.

Child and king face to face

Chapter 113 is the scene of recognition. Astyages, having received Artembares's complaint, summons both Mitradates and Cyrus. He questions Cyrus directly: why did you, a slave's son, beat the son of this man? Cyrus replies without fear: because he was playing the role of one of my subjects in our game, and he deserved it. The answer is not an apology; it is a defense. Astyages studies the child carefully — his features, his manner, his age. Something in the boy's face is familiar, and when he calculates the age — about ten years, which would match the child he ordered killed — the alarm begins. He dismisses Artembares with compensation, separates Cyrus from Mitradates, and interrogates the herdsman alone. The scene is a masterpiece of understatement: the reader knows what Astyages is beginning to suspect, and the tension is entirely in what he doesn't yet say.

The herdsman breaks under pressure

Chapter 114 covers the interrogation and confession of Mitradates. Once Cyrus is removed and Artembares dismissed, Astyages turns on the herdsman with a changed manner. He threatens him — exactly what the threat is Herodotus does not specify, but the context makes clear it is severe. Mitradates holds out briefly, then confesses everything: the child Harpagus brought him, his wife's refusal to expose it, the substitution of their stillborn son, the raising of the royal infant as their own. The whole secret of ten years is out in the space of an interrogation. Astyages sends for Harpagus next. The chapter closes the childhood section: Cyrus's identity is now known to Astyages, to Harpagus (who will shortly be confronted), and to the reader who has been watching the whole mechanism unfold.

The official who delegated too much

Chapter 115 covers the confrontation between Astyages and Harpagus. Harpagus arrives at the palace. Astyages asks him what happened to the infant he was given. Harpagus reads the room — Astyages knows something, but how much? — and calculates his answer. He says he gave the child to the shepherd after finding he could not bring himself to kill the royal bloodline. He had arranged for the shepherd to expose it, and the shepherd confirmed the child was dead. He asks what happened to the child. Astyages, now certain Harpagus is partly lying and partly in the dark about Cyrus's survival, tells him the child is alive and well. The chapter is a study in partial information and the dynamics of a court interrogation: both men are measuring how much the other knows, and neither is saying everything.

Dream discharged in children's play

Chapter 116 is the scene of deliberate self-deception. Having confirmed that Cyrus is alive, Astyages convenes the Magi again and lays out the situation: the child he thought dead is alive, has played king among the village boys, and is now before him. The Magi deliberate and return with a comfortable interpretation: the dream said Mandane's son would be king, and he has been — in the boys' game. The small fulfillment has discharged the larger prophecy; the cosmic obligation has been met in miniature. Astyages wants to believe this. He does believe it, or rather he chooses to act as if he does. The chapter is a penetrating study of how power and wishful thinking interact in the Herodotean world: the consultants tell the powerful man what he wants to hear, and he allows himself to be told.

The Persian son restored

Chapter 117 covers Cyrus's restoration to his biological family. Satisfied by the Magi's interpretation and having punished Harpagus (the feast of his son's flesh was served in the previous session — Herodotus here completes the chronological picture), Astyages sends Cyrus to Persia to join Cambyses and Mandane, his actual parents. Cyrus goes. He arrives in Persia and learns the story of his birth, the dreams, the shepherd, the ten years of a false life. The reunion with Mandane, who had believed her son dead for a decade, is noted briefly by Herodotus — he is not a sentimentalist — but the structural significance is complete: Cyrus is now in Persia, with his real identity known to himself and to the Persian nobility, growing up as the rightful heir to a future claim on both the Persian and Median thrones.

The banquet's long revenge

Chapter 118 opens the conspiracy that will topple Astyages. Harpagus, who received his son's remains at the banquet with outward composure, has been waiting. When Cyrus reaches maturity in Persia and is in a position to take military action, Harpagus begins sending messages — concealed in the belly of a hare, according to Herodotus, so that they would pass through the checkpoints on the road without detection. The message is direct: Harpagus has the support of the Median nobles, who resent Astyages. If Cyrus raises an army in Persia, Harpagus will defect with his forces and deliver victory. The chapter is the narrative payoff of the banquet scene twenty chapters earlier: the composure Harpagus showed when confronted with his son's remains was the composure of a man with a long memory and a plan.

Two days of labor, one of rest

Chapter 119 describes one of the most celebrated episodes in Book 1: Cyrus's method for testing — and then creating — Persian commitment to revolt. Having received Harpagus's offer, Cyrus needs to know whether the Persians will follow him against Astyages. He devises a test. He summons the Persian clans to a great clearing, sets them to hard labor cutting thorns for a day, and then the next day prepares a feast of meat and wine and gives them a day of ease and pleasure. At the end he asks which day they would prefer to repeat. The answer is the feast, obviously. Cyrus then explains: if they follow him, their lives will be like the feast day; if they continue under Astyages, their lives will be like the labor day. The Persians commit to the rebellion.

Appointing your own destroyer

Chapter 120 is the moment of perfect irony in the Astyages narrative. Learning that Cyrus has raised the Persians in revolt, Astyages has one more dream: he dreams that a vine grows from Mandane's womb and covers all of Asia — the same dream as before, now coming true at military scale. He calls the Magi, who confirm that the prophecy is in fact being fulfilled and that the child is an actual threat. Astyages's response is to mobilize the Median army and appoint Harpagus as its commander. He has apparently forgotten, or chosen to forget, what he did to Harpagus's son at the banquet. He is sending the man with the deepest personal grievance against him to command the army that stands between him and destruction. Herodotus notes the irony in his flat, unsentimental way and lets it speak.

book-i-chapter-121

book-i-chapter-122

book-i-chapter-123

book-i-chapter-124

book-i-chapter-125

book-i-chapter-126

book-i-chapter-127

book-i-chapter-128

book-i-chapter-129

book-i-chapter-130

book-i-chapter-131

book-i-chapter-132

book-i-chapter-133

book-i-chapter-134

book-i-chapter-135

book-i-chapter-136

book-i-chapter-137

book-i-chapter-138

book-i-chapter-139

book-i-chapter-140

book-i-chapter-141

book-i-chapter-142

book-i-chapter-143

book-i-chapter-144

book-i-chapter-145

book-i-chapter-146

book-i-chapter-147

book-i-chapter-148

book-i-chapter-149

book-i-chapter-150

Sparta's refusal and the Spartan envoy to Cyrus

The embassy to Sparta reads like a study in the gap between ceremonial politics and actual power. The Phocaian Pythermos dresses in purple to draw a crowd, delivers his appeal, and is dismissed. What Sparta does instead is more interesting than what it refuses: it sends a fifty-oared galley to Phocaia and then on to Sardis, where the envoy Lacrines delivers a formal Spartan warning that Cyrus must harm no Greek city. It is the kind of warning a great power issues when it wants to be on record without committing to action — a gesture that costs nothing. Herodotus notes the whole business with characteristic dry economy.

Cyrus scorns the Spartans and leaves Ionia to a subordinate

Cyrus's response to the Spartan warning is one of Herodotus's finest set-pieces of cultural collision. Cyrus does not know who the Spartans are. He has to ask. When told, he produces a contemptuous aphorism about men who gather in a market-place to trade and deceive each other with false oaths — a Persian's view of Greek civic commerce — and declares he has never feared such people. The remark is aimed not just at Sparta but at Greeks in general; Herodotus adds the gloss that Persians have no market-places and do not use them, which is why the insult has that shape. Cyrus then hands the whole Ionian problem to his subordinate Tabalos, gives the gold of Sardis to the Lydian Pactyas, and marches east toward Agbatana with Croesus in tow. Babylon, Bactria, the Sacae, and Egypt are waiting.

Pactyas revolts and besieges Sardis

The speed of the Lydian revolt makes the point Herodotus is building toward: entrusting gold and local authority to a native magnate is an invitation to trouble. Pactyas has exactly the resources — cash and coastal connections — to make himself dangerous the moment Cyrus leaves. He goes down to the sea, uses Croesus's gold to hire foreign soldiers, persuades the coastal peoples to join him, and leads them back to Sardis, where he shuts the Persian Tabalos up in the citadel. It is a classic ancient siege: the city below rebels while the garrison holds the height. Cyrus learns of it on the march.

Cyrus considers enslaving the Lydians; Croesus intercedes

The exchange between Cyrus and Croesus is one of the great moments of practical wisdom in the Histories. Cyrus's analogy is exact and bitter: he is like a man who killed the father but spared the sons, and now the sons are rebelling. Why should he be surprised? Croesus, who has every reason to care about what happens to Sardis, recognizes that if he doesn't offer Cyrus a persuasive alternative Cyrus will not change course. So he addresses the situation structurally. The Lydians, he says, are not to blame for the revolt — Pactyas is. Punish Pactyas. Pardon the Lydians, but disarm them, dress them in tunics and buskins, teach their sons to play the lyre and trade, and within a generation they will be women rather than men. The advice is at once protective and devastating.

Croesus's calculation and Cyrus's command to Mazares

Herodotus pauses to unpack the psychology behind Croesus's advice. Croesus was not acting from pure benevolence toward the Lydians; he feared that if the Lydians escaped present destruction they might revolt again at some future moment and then be annihilated. The counsel was the counsel of a man who had thought the problem through. This is characteristic of Herodotus at his most perceptive: he does not let the elegance of the Croesus-as-wise-advisor image obscure the calculation underneath it. Cyrus, satisfied, instructs Mazares to proclaim the new conditions to the Lydians, sell into slavery all who had joined Pactyas's expedition against Sardis, and above all to bring Pactyas himself back alive.

Pactyas flees to Kyme; Mazares sends for his surrender

The Pactyas episode now pivots from revolt into the political geography of the Ionian coast — a succession of cities that will have to decide whether to shelter or deliver a man who has thrown himself on their mercy. Kyme is first. Mazares, a Mede, takes the portion of Cyrus's army left behind and moves on Sardis, finding no rebels there. He enforces Cyrus's new arrangements on the Lydians and then sends north to Kyme demanding Pactyas. The men of Kyme do what cautious people do when a powerful demand meets an uncomfortable obligation: they consult the oracle.

The oracle at Branchidai orders Pactyas's surrender

The consultation at Branchidai puts Kyme in an uncomfortable position: the oracle, the most authoritative religious institution in Ionia, tells them to surrender the suppliant. Surrendering suppliants is sacrilege; this is axiomatic in Greek religion. The oracle has apparently told them to commit sacrilege. Aristodicos — described as a man of repute, which means someone the assembly will listen to — refuses to accept the answer at face value. He suspects the envoys misreported it, or the god has been misunderstood. He moves that a second embassy be sent, and he himself joins it. The logic of doubt is what Herodotus shows here: the answer doesn't fit the framework, so the framework must be defended by going back.

Aristodicos challenges the oracle; the god answers

This chapter is one of the most extraordinary theological exchanges in all of ancient literature. Aristodicos arrives at Branchidai, receives the same answer — surrender Pactyas — and proceeds to walk around the temple methodically destroying every bird-nest he can find: sparrows, swallows, whatever has taken refuge under the god's eaves. A voice from the inner shrine stops him: most impious of men, what are you doing? You are removing my suppliants. And Aristodicos says, with a precision that must have made every Greek who heard it catch their breath: Then why do you bid us hand over ours? The god's reply is devastating: so that you may be destroyed the more quickly for your impiety, and not come to the oracle again to ask about handing over suppliants. It is not a justification. It is a curse and a dismissal. The oracle knows it is telling them to do wrong, and says so — the point being that Kyme, which came to ask about this, deserves what it gets for even framing the question.

Pactyas handed over by the Chians; Atarneus and the cursed grain

Pactyas's journey through the Ionian cities is a study in moral evasion under pressure. No city wants to surrender him; no city is willing to keep him at the cost of Persian wrath. Kyme sends him to Mytilene rather than decide. Mytilene begins negotiating a price. Kyme hears about the negotiation and ships him off to Chios before the deal closes. The Chians commit the act the others avoided: they drag Pactyas out of the temple of Athene Poliuchos — out of sanctuary — and hand him to the Persians in exchange for the district of Atarneus. Herodotus closes the episode with a detail that has the precision of a folk-memory: for a long time afterward, no Chian ever used grain grown in Atarneus for a sacred offering. The territory itself was contaminated by the act.

Mazares punishes the Ionians; death of Mazares

Mazares appears in the Histories as a minor but efficient instrument of Persian revenge. Having secured Pactyas, he turns to the cities that had supported the rebellion against Tabalos. Priene is reduced to slavery. The plain of the Maeander is stripped of its produce and handed over to the Persian army as plunder. Magnesia receives the same treatment. Then Mazares falls sick and dies — a sudden, flat sentence that ends his career. Herodotus moves immediately to the appointment of his successor.

Harpagos takes command; the mound-siege system

The appointment of Harpagos brings back into the narrative one of the Histories' most shadowed figures. Herodotus identifies him with a parenthetical that carries enormous weight: this was the man whom Astyages feasted with the unlawful banquet — the scene in Book 1 where Astyages served Harpagos his own son's flesh as revenge for disobeying an order to kill the infant Cyrus. Harpagos took his revenge by defecting to Cyrus at the critical moment, which is how Cyrus overthrew the Medes. Now Harpagos comes to Ionia in Cyrus's service, and he brings a new method: the earth-mound. Rather than prolonged blockade, he raises a mound of earth against each city's wall and takes it by storm from above. It is systematic, slow, and irresistible. Phocaia is first.

The Phocaians: great sailors and their friendship with Arganthonios

Before telling us how Phocaia falls, Herodotus steps back to characterize the city. The Phocaians are not ordinary sailors: they are the pioneers of long-distance exploration in the Greek world. They reached Tartessos — the legendary rich city at the western end of the Mediterranean, perhaps near modern Cadiz — and struck up a friendship with its king Arganthonios, whose lifespan Herodotus reports as 80 years of rule and 120 years of life. Arganthonios liked the Phocaians so much he tried to get them to settle permanently in Tartessos; when they declined he gave them a substantial sum of money to wall their city against the Medes. The wall thus built is many furlongs in circuit and made of great close-fitted stones. Herodotus gives this with a note of genuine wonder: here is the wealth and longevity of the far west, brought in contact with the Greek east.

The Phocaians abandon their city rather than submit

The Phocaian response to siege is one of the more extraordinary collective decisions in the Histories. Harpagos offers generous terms — throw down one battlement, dedicate a single house, and the matter is settled. The Phocaians ask for one day to deliberate. Harpagos, knowing perfectly well what they mean to do but granting it anyway, withdraws his army. The Phocaians use the day to launch their fifty-oared galleys, load them with children, women, portable goods, and everything from the temples except bronze, stone, and paintings, and sail away. They sail to Chios and propose to buy the Oinussai islands from the Chians for a new home. Herodotus's account of the one-day ruse is told without explicit admiration, but the shape of it — the formal request for deliberation, the quiet evacuation — carries unmistakable respect.

The Phocaians sail for Kyrnos; the oath broken and kept

The episode of the mass oath is psychologically exact. The Phocaians, committed to exile, sail back to Phocaia, slaughter the Persian garrison Harpagos had installed, and perform a solemn act: they sink a lump of iron in the sea and swear that none will return to Phocaia before that iron rises to the surface again. This is the definitive form of a never-oath — the iron will never float, so they will never return. But the moment they weigh anchor for Kyrnos, more than half the company is seized by homesickness and turns back, breaking the oath and sailing home to the city they have just formally renounced. Those who kept the oath continue to Kyrnos. Herodotus reports this without judgment; the numbers tell the story. The free people who chose exile over subjection turned out to be the minority of the people who made that choice.

The sea-battle of Alalia; Phocaian 'Cadmean victory'

The Battle of Alalia around 540 BCE is one of the earliest naval engagements Herodotus records, and he frames it with the phrase Cadmean victory — a Greek idiom for a victory that ruins the winner. The Phocaians win the naval encounter; the Carthaginians and Etruscans cannot hold the sea. But forty of the sixty Phocaian ships are sunk or crippled, with their rams bent aside and useless. The survivors cannot stay at Alalia without a fighting fleet. They pick up their women and children from the island — again, their whole community reduced to what their ships can carry — and sail south to Rhegion in Italy. The episode has the quality of a parable about the difference between prevailing in a battle and sustaining a cause. The Phocaians have now been expelled twice: first from Phocaia by Harpagos, now from Kyrnos by their own naval victory.

The Agyllaean stoning and its religious consequences

This chapter is a piece of divine mechanics that Herodotus records with careful neutrality. The men of Agylla — the Etruscan city — stone their Phocaian prisoners after the battle. Later, anything that passes the spot where the Phocaians were killed — animals, people — becomes paralyzed or distorted. The Agyllaeans recognize they have done something that has poisoned the land, and they consult Delphi. The Pythian oracle prescribes the remedy: regular great sacrifices to the dead Phocaians and athletic and equestrian games in their honor. The Agyllaeans have performed this ritual ever since. Herodotus is careful to note that the surviving Phocaians who reached Rhegion eventually founded the city of Hyele in southern Italy — having learned from a man of Poseidonia that the oracle's reference to Kyrnos meant the hero Kyrnos, not the island. The distinction mattered: found a temple, not a colony.

The men of Teos found Abdera

The Teos episode is a compressed parallel to the Phocaian story — compressed, Herodotus says, because nearly the same thing happened. Once Harpagos's mound-siege takes the wall, the Teïans do not wait for terms: they embark in their ships and sail to Thrace. There they found Abdera, on a site that another Greek, Timesios of Clazomenae, had previously founded and been driven out of by the Thracians. Timesios got no benefit from his founding; the Teïans now honor him as a hero in Abdera. It is the kind of compressed detail Herodotus includes not for the story's sake but to fill in the geography of Greek colonization: every city in the Greek world has a prior history.

Ionia reduced; only Miletos holds out by treaty

Herodotus marks the closure of the Ionian conquest with a careful distinction. The Phocaians and Teïans chose exile; the other Ionians except the Milesians fought — they were brave — and when they lost they stayed. Herodotus does not condemn this. The brave man who loses and submits is not dishonored; resistance has been tried and failed. The Milesians are the conspicuous exception in the other direction: they had sworn a separate agreement directly with Cyrus and held to it, which means they never fought and were never conquered. They simply watched while everyone around them was brought under Persian rule. Herodotus gives this with neutral completeness: for the second time, Ionia was enslaved.

Bias of Priene and Thales of Miletos: two counsels on Ionian survival

Herodotus inserts a double digression on political wisdom at the moment when wisdom has become academic. Both counsels are presented as the most profitable proposals the Ionians ever received and did not follow. Bias of Priene urged that the Ionian cities pool their resources, sail together to Sardinia — the largest island in the Mediterranean — and found a single pan-Ionian city. They would be rich, free, and rulers of others instead of subjects. This is the counsel given after the ruin. Thales of Miletos offered the other counsel before it: a single deliberative chamber at Teos, the geographically central city, while all the other Ionian cities remained inhabited but subordinate to it. Both proposals share the same structural insight: Greek cities are strong individually, fatal separately. Neither was adopted. Herodotus ends the sequence with a sentence of such compressed wryness — these men set forth to them counsels of the kind I have said — that it needs no commentary.

Harpagos marches on Caria; the origins of the Carians

With Ionia completed, Harpagos moves south along the Anatolian coast to the peoples of Caria, Caunia, and Lycia, taking Ionians and Aeolians along as auxiliary troops. Herodotus uses the occasion for an ethnographic origin-account of the Carians, who have an unusually well-developed self-mythology. The Cretans say they came from the islands, where they were subjects of Minos and served as his sailors without paying tribute — they were prominent and capable people. They then invented three things the Hellenes adopted: crests on helmets, devices painted on shields, and handles for shields (before which shields were managed by a neck-strap and left-shoulder strap, like a quiver). Herodotus includes both accounts of Carian origin — the island account from Crete and the mainland-aboriginal account the Carians themselves prefer — and declines to adjudicate.

The customs of the Caunians: drinking festivals and expelling foreign gods

The Caunians are a people Herodotus finds deeply interesting because their customs differ sharply from those of everyone around them — Carians, Greeks, and everyone else. The communal drinking by mixed age and gender groups is one oddity; the god-expulsion episode is another of an entirely different kind. At some point the Caunians had accumulated a collection of foreign deities — acquired through trade, contact, or conquest. Then they changed their minds. The young men of the city put on their armor, took up their spears, and marched in formation to the borders of their territory, beating the air with their weapons and chanting that they were expelling the foreign gods. Herodotus reports this without comment, which is itself a kind of comment: the sight of an armed procession symbolically beating gods out of a country with spear-shafts is precisely the kind of thing that his reader is supposed to hold in mind next to Greek, Persian, and Egyptian religious practice.

The origins of the Lycians; matrilineal descent

The Lycian digression is one of the most ethnographically precise in the Histories. Herodotus traces their origin to Crete: when Minos and his brother Sarpedon quarreled over the kingship of Crete, Minos won and expelled Sarpedon with his faction. They arrived in Milyas, the region the Lycians now inhabit, and were called Termilae. When Lycos, son of Pandion, was later expelled from Athens by his brother Aegeus and came to the Termilae, they eventually took his name and became Lycians. Their customs are a blend of Cretan and Carian. But their most distinctive and unique practice is matrilineal descent: they name themselves after their mothers, not their fathers. If a citizen woman marries a slave, the children are considered freeborn citizens; if a citizen man takes a slave wife or concubine, the children have no civic standing. Herodotus notes this as something no other people do — unique among the peoples of the known world.

Caria falls; the Cnidians try to dig through an isthmus and are stopped by Delphi

The reduction of Caria proper is brief — Herodotus acknowledges it was achieved without notable deeds on either side — but the Cnidian episode is a gem. The men of Cnidos, colonists from Sparta settled on a peninsula with the sea nearly surrounding them, decide to complete what geography started: they will dig through the narrow neck of land that connects them to the mainland and make themselves an island. The project is militarily rational — an island is harder to besiege with a mound. But the workmen suffer strange injuries, far beyond ordinary accident, especially to their eyes when the rock is struck. They consult Delphi. The oracle answers in trimeter: do not fence the place with towers, do not dig through the isthmus. If Zeus had wanted your land to be an island, he would have made it one. The Cnidians stop digging and surrender to Harpagos without resistance when he arrives.

The Pedasians and the bearded priestess of Athene

The Pedasians are introduced through their sign rather than their strategy. The detail of the bearded priestess is exactly the kind of local marvel Herodotus collects and preserves without rationalization: whenever something harmful is about to happen to Pedasa or its neighbors, the priestess of Athene grows a full beard. This had occurred three times by Herodotus's knowledge. The Pedasians were, of all the peoples around Caria, the ones who gave Harpagos the most trouble, holding out on their fortified mountain of Lide. Herodotus notes it with simple admiration for their persistence before moving to describe their eventual fall.

The mass suicide at Xanthos; Lycia falls

The fall of Xanthos is one of the most extreme episodes of collective self-destruction in the Histories and perhaps in all of ancient literature. The Lycians fight Harpagos in the open field, few against many, with notable courage. Driven back into Xanthos, they gather their women, children, servants, and possessions into the citadel and set it on fire. Then, with the city burning, they swear oaths to one another, march out, and die in battle against the Persians. Every man of Xanthos is killed. Herodotus adds: the Xanthians who claim Lycian ancestry in his own time are almost all immigrants except eighty families who happened to be away when the city burned. The act is total and deliberate — a kind of civic suicide in the face of slavery — and Herodotus describes it without editorial comment. The Caunians imitated the Lycian behavior in most respects, Herodotus notes, and they too fall.

Cyrus turns to the upper lands; Babylon stands in the way

This chapter is a transitional hinge. Herodotus acknowledges that Cyrus was engaged in constant conquest across the upper regions of Asia while Harpagos worked the coast — he was not idle — but he sets aside most of those campaigns as not sufficiently remarkable or sufficiently documented. What remains worth telling in full is the campaign against Babylon. The statement is a promise: the city I am about to describe is so extraordinary that it earns its own account. The description of Babylon that follows is one of the great architectural ethnographies in the Histories.

The walls and dimensions of Babylon

Herodotus's description of Babylon is one of the most sustained architectural passages in the Histories and is presented as personal knowledge — he has been there, or has sources who have. The dimensions are staggering by any ancient standard: a square city with sides of 120 furlongs each, giving a circuit of 480 furlongs. The surrounding trench is deep and broad and full of water. The wall uses royal cubits — a cubit somewhat larger than the common measure. The thickness of 50 royal cubits and the height of 200 cubits are almost certainly round-number estimates, but they tell the reader what Babylon was meant to communicate: impregnable, permanent, the work of a civilization confident in its staying power. One hundred bronze gates are mentioned. What strikes Herodotus and his reader is that this city was not Nineveh, which is gone; it is the new seat of Assyrian monarchy, built for permanence after the old capital fell.

The wall's construction method; the asphalt from the river Is

Herodotus is interested not just in the dimensions but in the supply chain. How did a city on a plain — no stone available — build walls of that size? The answer is the Mesopotamian brick tradition: the trench provides the clay, which is molded into bricks and baked in kilns. The bricks are bound with hot bitumen instead of lime mortar; reed mats are inserted every thirty courses as a kind of seismic reinforcement or simply to bind the layers. The bitumen itself arrives from a specific source: a small river eight days' journey from Babylon called the Is, which flows into the Euphrates and brings floating lumps of asphalt with its current. The detail is precisely the kind of logistical inquiry that distinguishes Herodotus from a simple wonder-recorder: he wants to know how things work, where materials come from, how the system holds together. He adds that the river Is also gives its name to a city.

The Euphrates divides Babylon; the riverside walls and the street grid

Herodotus's Babylon is divided into two halves by the Euphrates, and the river is part of the city's defensive system as much as its commerce. The wall bends down to the river on each side, and along each bank runs a rampart of baked brick matching the main wall. Inside the city, the streets are straight — a grid in the Mesopotamian tradition — and they run all the way to the river. At the point where each street meets the riverside rampart, there is a small gate of bronze that opens to stairs leading down to the river itself. You could walk from anywhere in the city straight to the water. The description is that of a city that has thought systematically about access and defense at the same time.

The palace, the temple of Bel, and the eight-tiered ziggurat

This final chapter of the Babylonian description gives the city its two sacred and royal centers. Each half of the city, divided by the Euphrates, has a great building at its heart. One is the royal palace, fortified and extensive. The other is the precinct of Bel — Marduk, chief deity of Babylon — with its famous stepped tower, the ziggurat that stood behind the later Greek and Jewish traditions of the Tower of Babel. Herodotus counts eight towers built one upon another with an external ramp spiraling around the outside; at the middle of the ascent there is a rest-platform with seats. On the topmost tower is a single large cell with a finely covered couch and a golden table. There is no cult image. No one sleeps there except a single native woman chosen by the god, as the Chaldaean priests report. Herodotus adds that the Egyptians claim something similar happens at Thebes in the temple of Zeus — a woman kept in the temple's innermost chamber as wife of the god. He is recording a religious practice that corresponds across cultures without claiming to explain it.

The god in the inner cell — divine presence at Babylon and Thebes

The golden statue of Zeus at Babylon — the great altar and its sacrifices

Semiramis and Nitocris — two queens who ruled Babylon

Nitocris fortifies Babylon against the Medes

Nitocris builds the bridge of Babylon

Nitocris's tomb — the inscription above the city gate

The last king of Babylon — Labynetos son of Nitocris

Cyrus punishes the river Gyndes — three hundred and sixty channels

Cyrus advances on Babylon — the Babylonians give battle and are driven within their walls

Cyrus takes Babylon — the army enters through the diverted Euphrates

Babylon's wealth — the tribute that sustains the Persian king

Agriculture in Assyria — the Babylonian grain harvest and irrigation

The round leather boats of Babylon — coracles on the Euphrates

Babylonian dress and customs — anointing, staffs, and seals

The Babylonian bride auction — the wisest custom Herodotus knows

Babylonian medicine — the sick in the marketplace

Babylonian burial, marital ritual, and the practices of the Arabians

Sacred prostitution at the temple of Aphrodite in Babylon

Fish-eating tribes of Babylonia — three tribes and their practices

Cyrus turns his ambition eastward — the Massagetai beyond the Araxes

The Araxes river and the islands of the haoma-drinkers

The Caspian Sea — a lake apart, not joined to the Mediterranean

The Caucasus and the great plain — home of the Massagetai

Queen Tomyris of the Massagetai rejects Cyrus's marriage proposal

Tomyris warns Cyrus — the choice of battlefield

Croesus counsels Cyrus — the wine trap strategy against the Massagetai

Cyrus adopts Croesus's stratagem and crosses the Araxes

Cyrus summons Hystaspes — sending Darius back to Persia under watch

The wine trap succeeds — the Massagetai army destroyed and Spargapises taken

The death of Cyrus — Tomyris's revenge and the end of the conqueror

the-histories-book-1-chapter-212

the-histories-book-1-chapter-213

the-histories-book-1-chapter-214

the-histories-book-1-chapter-215

the-histories-book-1-chapter-216

the-histories-book-2-chapter-1

the-histories-book-2-chapter-2

the-histories-book-2-chapter-3

the-histories-book-2-chapter-4

the-histories-book-2-chapter-5

the-histories-book-2-chapter-6

the-histories-book-2-chapter-7

the-histories-book-2-chapter-8

the-histories-book-2-chapter-9

the-histories-book-2-chapter-10

the-histories-book-2-chapter-11

the-histories-book-2-chapter-12

the-histories-book-2-chapter-13

the-histories-book-2-chapter-14

the-histories-book-2-chapter-15

the-histories-book-2-chapter-16

the-histories-book-2-chapter-17

the-histories-book-2-chapter-18

the-histories-book-2-chapter-19

the-histories-book-2-chapter-20

the-histories-book-2-chapter-21

the-histories-book-2-chapter-22

the-histories-book-2-chapter-23

the-histories-book-2-chapter-24

the-histories-book-2-chapter-25

Why Libya stays dry

Herodotus offers a theoretical explanation for Libya's climate: the sun burns the air dry as it passes overhead, producing constant summer heat in the upper regions. He connects this hypothesis to his broader inquiry into why the Nile floods annually, framing the climate as an effect of the sun's seasonal position rather than supernatural causes. The reasoning is speculative but systematic.

No breeze from heat

Continuing his natural-philosophical inquiry, Herodotus addresses a puzzle: why does no cooling breeze come off the Nile in summer? His answer is that breezes originate from cold regions, not hot ones. This brief chapter exemplifies his attempt to build a coherent meteorological theory based on observation and analogy rather than divine intervention.

The Nile's unknown source

Herodotus declares that despite consulting Egyptians, Libyans, and Greeks, no one could identify the Nile's source. The chapter marks a turning point from atmospheric theory to geographic inquiry, underscoring the limits of ancient knowledge. Herodotus treats the admission honestly, distinguishing between what he heard and what he himself could verify.

Herodotus travels to Elephantine

Herodotus tells us he personally traveled as far as Elephantine, the southernmost city of Egypt, to investigate the Nile. Beyond that point he depends on the reports of others. This chapter is important for understanding how he calibrates his evidence: eyewitness observation carries greater weight than secondhand accounts, and he flags the transition clearly.

The Deserters of Egypt

Herodotus describes a settlement called 'the Deserters,' founded by Egyptian soldiers who defected to Ethiopia during the reign of Psammetichus. He reports their descendants still live there. The account blends geographic reportage with a tale of military desertion, illustrating how political events could reshape populations across vast distances.

Four months up the Nile

Herodotus summarizes how far the Nile is known: a four-month journey combining river travel and overland sections from the Egyptian delta southward. Beyond that, the river enters uninhabited regions and becomes unknowable. The chapter establishes the practical limits of ancient geographic knowledge through time-based measurement rather than linear distance.

Nasamonians reach a great river

Herodotus recounts a multi-layered tale. Men from Cyrene told him of their visit to Etearchus, king of the Ammonians, who in turn told them about young Nasamonian adventurers who crossed the Libyan desert and reached a large river flowing westward, full of crocodiles. Herodotus suspects this is the upper Niger, though he tentatively connects it to the Nile.

A cautious end to the Nile debate

Herodotus wraps up the story of the Nasamonian explorers with characteristic intellectual caution. He accepts that they reached a river but refuses to identify it definitively with the Nile, noting that the direction of flow (westward) argues against it. He reports what he heard without imposing more certainty than the evidence supports.

Nile vs. Ister compared

Herodotus draws a symmetrical comparison between the Nile and the Ister (Danube): both rivers originate in the west and flow east, but the Ister passes through populated territory whose inhabitants can report on it, while the Nile flows through desert where no one lives to observe. Accessibility of human witnesses, not geography alone, determines what can be known.

Egypt, land of wonders

With the Nile inquiry concluded, Herodotus pivots to his full ethnographic survey of Egypt. He frames Egypt as uniquely worthy of attention — more wonders than any other land, a climate and river unlike any other. He introduces his core observation: the Egyptians have adopted customs opposite to those of all other peoples, as if deliberately inverting human norms.

Priests shave their heads

Herodotus opens his catalogue of Egyptian customs with the priests: unlike other nations where priests wear long hair, Egyptian priests shave their heads. He also notes that Egyptians shave in mourning while other peoples let their hair grow, and that Egyptians live with their animals while other nations keep them separate. Each observation exemplifies the inversion he announced in the previous chapter.

Purity and bronze cups

Herodotus describes Egyptian religious scrupulousness: they rinse bronze cups every day, wear freshly washed linen, circumcise for cleanliness, and shave their entire bodies every other day so that no lice or impurity can contaminate their sacred service. The overall portrait is of a people whose daily life is organized around ritual purity to a degree unmatched elsewhere.

Testing the sacred ox

Herodotus describes the Egyptian inspection ritual for sacrificial oxen: a priest examines the beast's entire body, including inside the mouth and on the tail, looking for any impurity or black hair. Only a clean beast receives a clay seal, allowing it to be used in sacrifice. Any imperfect animal is rejected. The detail and seriousness of the inspection underscores Egyptian religious scrupulousness.

The manner of sacrifice

The chapter details Egyptian sacrificial procedure: lead the sealed beast to the altar, light the fire, pour wine, invoke the god, and cut off the head — which is then cursed and, if there are Greek traders, sold to them, or else thrown into the river. The body is variously prepared depending on the deity. The head-cursing ritual (condemning it in place of the worshipper) particularly interested later commentators.

Isis sacrifice described

Herodotus says he will describe the greatest Egyptian sacrifice — to Isis — in detail, while acknowledging that different sacrifices are performed differently for different deities. The goddess Isis is depicted with the horns of a cow, an image Herodotus connects to Greek Io. The chapter introduces the particular sanctity of the cow in Egyptian religion.

Cows sacred to Isis

Herodotus explains that while clean male oxen are sacrificed throughout Egypt, female cattle are entirely prohibited from sacrifice because they are sacred to Isis. He notes that no Egyptian — man or woman — would kiss a Greek on the lips or use Greek utensils, because Greeks eat cows. This dietary/ritual prohibition creates a barrier between Egyptians and Greeks that Herodotus finds notable.

Goats at Thebes, rams at Mendes

Herodotus explains that Egyptian religious practice varies by district. Those with temples to Theban Zeus sacrifice goats but not sheep, because the Theban god is identified with a ram; those near Mendes do the opposite. The exception is Osiris and Isis, who are worshipped uniformly across Egypt. He notes that Thebans consider those who sacrifice sheep impious.

Heracles in Egypt

Herodotus pursues a bold comparative-religion argument: the Egyptians have worshipped Heracles for 17,000 years — far longer than the Greeks, who made him a demi-god. He visited a temple of Heracles in Egypt with two figures, the outer a divine Heracles and the inner a human one. The implication is that the Greeks borrowed and humanized a much older Egyptian deity.

Heracles temple at Tyre

To test his Heracles thesis further, Herodotus traveled to Tyre in Phoenicia to examine its temple of Heracles. He found the temple very ancient, with two sacred pillars — one of gold, one of emerald — and spoke with the priests about its antiquity. He then visited a second Heracles temple at Tyre called 'of the Thasian Heracles,' confirming regional variation in the cult.

The absurd Heracles myth

Herodotus dismisses a popular Greek myth: that Heracles was captured by Egyptians and nearly sacrificed before killing his captors. He argues this is logically absurd — the Egyptians are explicitly forbidden from sacrificing humans, and it is inherently contradictory that one man could overpower an entire nation. The passage is a rare moment of direct myth-critique.

Pan among the eight gods

Herodotus explains why Mendesians sacrifice neither goats nor male sheep: Pan is one of the eight gods who predated the twelve Olympians, and he is represented locally in goat form. The passage continues his investigation of how local animal prohibitions reflect local theologies. He presents the goat-Pan connection as a factual report from priests, not personal inference.

Pigs and Egyptian taboo

Herodotus describes the Egyptian pig taboo in detail: any Egyptian who accidentally touches a pig must immediately plunge into the Nile fully clothed to purify themselves. Swineherds, though Egyptian-born, are excluded from temples and from intermarrying with other Egyptians — a form of ritual pollution so severe it amounts to social exclusion. The pig taboo is among the most elaborate in Egyptian culture.

Pig sacrifice for Dionysus

Herodotus notes what appears to be a paradox: Egyptians find pigs abominable and exclude swineherds from society, yet they sacrifice pigs to Dionysus and the Moon on the full moon and eat the meat that day. He explains that the poor who cannot afford a pig shape dough into pig form and offer that instead. The exception reveals that the taboo is ritual, not absolute.

Melampus and Dionysus rites

Herodotus credits Melampus, son of Amytheon, with bringing the Dionysus cult to Greece, including the name, the sacrifice, and the phallic procession. Melampus, he argues, was not ignorant of these rites — he had learned from Cadmus of Tyre and those who came from Phoenicia, who themselves derived the knowledge from Egypt. The transmission chain: Egypt → Phoenicia → Greece.

Greek gods came from Egypt

Herodotus makes his broadest claim in Book 2: nearly all the names of Greek gods came from Egypt. He asserts he found this through careful inquiry and is confident the derivation is Egyptian, not from any other barbarian source. He acknowledges the Pelasgians — the pre-Greek inhabitants — as intermediaries, but maintains Egypt as the ultimate origin of Greek theology.

Hermes with the phallos — a Pelasgian addition

Herodotus qualifies his sweeping Egypt-origin thesis: the ithyphallic representation of Hermes was not adopted from Egypt but from the Pelasgians, the pre-Greek population of Attica. He describes how the Athenians adopted Pelasgian customs, including this one, before other Greeks followed. This is a rare acknowledgment in Book 2 that not all Greek religious elements derive from Egypt.

The Pelasgians learned gods' names

Herodotus reports what he learned at Dodona: the Pelasgians originally worshipped unnamed gods, calling them simply 'the gods who arranged all things.' They later adopted divine names from Dodona's oracle, which Herodotus elsewhere connects to Egyptian origins. This chapter deepens the transmission model: Egypt → Dodona → Pelasgians → Greeks.

Hesiod and Homer only yesterday

Herodotus makes a chronological argument that is remarkable for its boldness: Hesiod and Homer, who gave the Greek gods their characters, genealogies, and attributes, lived only 400 years before him — recently, in historical terms. The Greeks themselves did not know their gods' natures until these poets described them. This frames Hesiod and Homer not as receivers of ancient tradition but as creative inventors of the theology they transmitted.

Two doves flew from Thebes

The priests at the Theban temple of Zeus told Herodotus that two women in the service of the temple were carried off — one went to Libya, one to Greece (Dodona). Each founded an oracle. These women were called 'doves' by the Dodonans because they spoke in a foreign tongue that sounded like bird-calls. Herodotus presents this as one account of Dodona's origin.

Dodona's own account

Herodotus now gives the Dodonans' version: two black doves flew from Thebes in Egypt. One went to Libya and commanded the founding of the oracle of Ammon there. The other settled at Dodona in an oak tree and spoke, commanding an oracle be founded there. Herodotus presents both the Theban and Dodonean accounts without adjudicating between them, leaving the reader to compare.

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 56

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 57

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 58

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 59

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 60

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 61

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 62

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 63

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 64

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 65

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 66

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 67

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 68

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 69

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 70

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 71

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 72

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 73

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 74

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 75

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 76

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 77

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 78

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 79

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 80

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 81

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 82

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 83

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 84

Book 2 — Euterpe, Chapter 85

the-histories-book-2-chapter-86

the-histories-book-2-chapter-87

the-histories-book-2-chapter-88

the-histories-book-2-chapter-89

the-histories-book-2-chapter-90

the-histories-book-2-chapter-91

the-histories-book-2-chapter-92

the-histories-book-2-chapter-93

the-histories-book-2-chapter-94

the-histories-book-2-chapter-95

the-histories-book-2-chapter-96

the-histories-book-2-chapter-97

the-histories-book-2-chapter-98

the-histories-book-2-chapter-99

the-histories-book-2-chapter-100

the-histories-book-2-chapter-101

the-histories-book-2-chapter-102

the-histories-book-2-chapter-103

the-histories-book-2-chapter-104

the-histories-book-2-chapter-105

the-histories-book-2-chapter-106

the-histories-book-2-chapter-107

the-histories-book-2-chapter-108

the-histories-book-2-chapter-109

the-histories-book-2-chapter-110

the-histories-book-2-chapter-111

the-histories-book-2-chapter-112

the-histories-book-2-chapter-113

the-histories-book-2-chapter-114

the-histories-book-2-chapter-115

helen-egypt-alternative-account-trojan-war

cyprian-epic-homeric-authorship-herodotus

egyptian-priests-trojan-war-helen

menelaus-recovers-helen-egypt

herodotus-argues-helen-not-at-troy

rhampsinitos-gateway-hephaistos

rhampsinitos-hades-dice-demeter

herodotus-hearsay-limits-historical-knowledge

cheops-great-pyramid-egyptian-tyrant

great-pyramid-construction-machines-ramps

cheops-daughter-pyramid-gifts

chephren-pharaoh-second-pyramid-giza

one-hundred-six-years-closed-temples-egypt

mykerinos-just-king-reopened-temples

golden-cow-mykerinos-daughter-sais

mykerinos-daughter-incest-alternative-tradition

sacred-cow-sais-gold-crimson-lamps

oracle-buto-mykerinos-six-years

third-pyramid-giza-mykerinos-ethiopian-stone

rhodopis-courtesan-pyramid-legend-delphi

asychis-pyramid-brick-mortgage-law-egypt

blind-king-anysis-ethiopian-conquest-egypt

temple-buto-island-water-sacred-chasm

dream-ends-ethiopian-occupation-sabacos-departs

blind-king-anysis-returns-fifty-years-marshes

sethos-priest-pharaoh-sennacherib-invasion

341-generations-egyptian-kings-chronology

hecataeus-thebes-wooden-statues-priests

egyptian-divine-kings-greek-gods-contrast

heracles-dionysos-pan-egypt-older-than-greek

the-histories-book-2-chapter-146

the-histories-book-2-chapter-147

the-histories-book-2-chapter-148

the-histories-book-2-chapter-149

the-histories-book-2-chapter-150

the-histories-book-2-chapter-151

the-histories-book-2-chapter-152

the-histories-book-2-chapter-153

the-histories-book-2-chapter-154

the-histories-book-2-chapter-155

the-histories-book-2-chapter-156

the-histories-book-2-chapter-157

the-histories-book-2-chapter-158

the-histories-book-2-chapter-159

the-histories-book-2-chapter-160

the-histories-book-2-chapter-161

the-histories-book-2-chapter-162

the-histories-book-2-chapter-163

the-histories-book-2-chapter-164

the-histories-book-2-chapter-165

the-histories-book-2-chapter-166

the-histories-book-2-chapter-167

the-histories-book-2-chapter-168

the-histories-book-2-chapter-169

the-histories-book-2-chapter-170

the-histories-book-2-chapter-171

the-histories-book-2-chapter-172

the-histories-book-2-chapter-173

the-histories-book-2-chapter-174

the-histories-book-2-chapter-175

Amasis's colossal dedications

Book 2 closes its portrait of Amasis with a brief inventory of his largest dedications: a seventy-five-foot colossus lying before the temple of Hephaistos at Memphis, flanked by two twenty-foot attendant figures on the same base, and a matching colossus at Saïs. He also built the great temple of Isis at Memphis. The inventory is characteristic of Herodotus's Egypt — specific dimensions, named sites, a note that the works are still visible in his own time.

Egypt under Amasis

A single paragraph summarises the prosperity of the Amasis era: the highest count of inhabited towns ever recorded in Egypt (twenty thousand), maximum Nile gift, and a law requiring every citizen to declare an honest livelihood on pain of death. Herodotus notes that Solon took this law back to Athens, where it remained in force. The passage is compact but rich — the debt of Athenian law to Egyptian practice, the standard Herodotean method of citing the law's current observance as evidence of its soundness.

Naucratis and the Hellenion

Amasis's philhellenism finds its most concrete expression in the grant of Naucratis as a permanent residence and trading base for Greeks. The chapter lists the nine cities that jointly built the Hellenion — the great shared Greek sanctuary in Egypt — and names the individual sanctuaries established by Aigina (Zeus), Samos (Hera), and Miletos (Apollo). Herodotus is careful to note which cities have a genuine founding claim and which are latecomers.

Naucratis as sole trading port

A brief but precise chapter on the exclusive commercial status of Naucratis in the period before Amasis. Herodotus explains the enforcement mechanism: any merchant arriving at a mouth other than the Canobic was required to swear an oath of innocent intent and then either sail to the Canobic mouth or, if winds prevented, tranship the cargo overland around the Delta to Naucratis. The passage illustrates how trade was administratively controlled in Pharaonic Egypt and explains why Naucratis had such concentrated importance.

Amasis and the rebuilding of Delphi

A short chapter on Amasis's philhellenic generosity extending to the Greek sacred world. When the Delphians were raising funds to rebuild the temple that had burned, Amasis gave a thousand talents' weight of alum. The Greeks resident in Egypt added twenty pounds of silver. The chapter is characteristically Herodotean: a precise sum, a foreign king who participates in Greek religious life without being asked to convert to it, and the implicit point that Greek sacred architecture at Delphi was partly funded by an Egyptian pharaoh.

Amasis and Ladike

A brief and characteristically digressive Herodotean episode. Amasis married a Kyrenian woman named Ladike, and on the first night and for some time afterward was unable to have intercourse with her, though he had no such difficulty with his other wives. Convinced she had drugged him, he threatened her life. Ladike secretly vowed an image to Aphrodite in return for success; the vow worked at once. After Amasis grew greatly attached to her, she sent the image to Kyrene as promised. Herodotus closes with the note that when Cambyses later conquered Egypt and learned who Ladike was, he sent her home to Kyrene unharmed.

Amasis's offerings in Hellas

The final chapter of Book 2 proper summarises Amasis's dedications in the Greek world: a gold-covered image of Athene and a painted self-portrait at Kyrene; two stone statues and a linen corslet at the temple of Athene at Lindos; two wooden self-portraits at the Samian Heraion. Herodotus explains the rationale for each: the Samos dedications reflect guest-friendship with Polycrates, son of Aiakes; the Lindos dedications recall the tradition that the temple was founded by the daughters of Danaos. The chapter closes with the aside that Amasis was the first man to conquer Cyprus and impose tribute on it.

Cambyses marches on Egypt

The opening of Book 3 — Thalia — pivots from Egypt under Amasis to the Persian assault that ended Amasis's dynasty. Herodotus gives the Persian account of the war's origin: Cambyses asked Amasis for a daughter; Amasis, unwilling to give his own daughter as a concubine, dressed up Nitetis, the daughter of the murdered pharaoh Apries, in fine clothes and sent her as his own. When Cambyses greeted her as Amasis's daughter, she corrected him; Cambyses' anger followed. A secondary cause involves an Egyptian physician torn from his family by Amasis and sent to serve at the Persian court, who encouraged Cambyses to make the request as revenge.

The Egyptian counter-claim

Herodotus faithfully reports the Egyptian counter-narrative, then refutes it. The Egyptians claimed that it was Cyrus who sent to Amasis for a daughter, making Cambyses' mother an Egyptian and thus Cambyses himself a native of Egypt. Herodotus dismantles this: Persian succession law would never permit a bastard son to rule over a legitimate one; and Cambyses' mother was Cassandane the daughter of Pharnaspes, a fully Persian Achaemenid. The Egyptians are simply flattering themselves with a false kinship to the dynasty that conquered them.

Cambyses' childhood oath

Herodotus records a further etiological story, explicitly flagged as one he does not credit. A Persian woman visiting the court saw Cassandane's children and praised them extravagantly; Cassandane bitterly complained that Cyrus honoured the Egyptian woman Nitetis more than herself. The elder son Cambyses, aged about ten, said aloud: 'When I am a man I will turn Egypt upside down.' The women were amazed; Cambyses, the story claims, kept the vow in mind until he held power and made the expedition. Herodotus closes the anecdote with the flat statement that he does not believe it, but it was current and so he records it.

Phanes the deserter

A pivotal operational chapter: the defection of Phanes of Halicarnassos, a mercenary officer in Amasis's service, who fled Egypt by ship and made his way to Cambyses. Amasis recognised the danger and sent a trusted eunuch with a trireme after him; the eunuch captured Phanes in Lycia but was outwitted — Phanes got his guards drunk and escaped to Persia. Once there, Phanes provided Cambyses not only with intelligence on Egypt's affairs but with the critical strategic advice: ask the king of the Arabians for safe passage through the waterless region between Gaza and Egypt's border.

The approach to Egypt

A geographical interlude that establishes the strategic situation before Cambyses' march. The coastal strip from Phoenicia to Egypt is divided between Syrians (Palestinian territory), the Arab king, and Syrians again around the Serbonian lake. The Serbonian lake — where legend placed Typhon — marks the boundary of Egypt proper. Mount Casion runs beside it toward the sea. The region between Ienysos and the Serbonian lake, about three days' journey, has almost no water. This is the obstacle Phanes helped Cambyses solve.

The mystery of the wine jars

One of the most characteristically Herodotean digressions: a puzzle posed and then solved. Wine jars flood into Egypt from Greece and Phoenicia twice a year, yet none are visible lying about empty. Herodotus notes that few travellers have noticed this puzzle, implying that he is one who did. The next chapter will supply the answer. The pause serves the double purpose of demonstrating his method — attending to what others overlook — and illustrating the interconnection of Egyptian administration with its strategic situation.

The wine jars' fate

The answer to the puzzle posed in the previous chapter. Local headmen collect all empty jars, send them to Memphis; the Memphites fill them with water and ship them to the waterless region of Syria — the desert approach to Egypt. It was the Persians who systematised this supply chain from the moment they first took Egypt. At the time of Cambyses' march the system was not yet in place, which is why Phanes's advice to negotiate with the Arabian king was necessary: Cambyses had to arrange an alternative supply before the Persian administrative machine had been established.

Arabian pledges of friendship

A focused ethnographic chapter on the pledge ceremony of the Arabians. A neutral third party draws blood from the thumbs of both parties, smears it on seven stones laid between them while invoking Dionysos and Urania, and commends the stranger to the care of friends who are bound to respect the pledge. Herodotus notes that the Arabians worship only two gods: Dionysos (whom they call Orotalt) and Urania (whom they call Alilat), and that they cut their hair in a circle — the same way, they say, that Dionysos cuts his. The chapter establishes the sacred character of the pledge Cambyses is about to seek.

The Arab king supplies the water

The Arab king honours his pledge to Cambyses by solving the water problem in one of two ways — Herodotus reports both, noting that he finds the first more credible. In the credible version, the king loads water-filled camel skins on all available live camels and drives them to the waterless region. In the less credible but current version, a conduit pipe of sewn ox-hides twelve days' journey long conducted water from the Corys river to three different points in the desert. Herodotus invokes his standard disclaimer — he must record what is said without being obliged to believe it — and prefers the camels.

Psammenitos at the Pelusian mouth

Cambyses arrived too late to face Amasis: the pharaoh had died after a reign of forty-four years, having been embalmed and buried in his own temple tomb. His son Psammenitos waited at the Pelusian mouth of the Nile. Herodotus inserts a prodigy: rain fell at Thebes — something the Thebans say had never happened before and has not happened since in living memory. Upper Egypt receives no rain at all; this shower was therefore interpreted as a sign. The juxtaposition of the undramatic death of Amasis and the ominous portent sets the stage for the battle.

The battle at Pelusium

The battle of Pelusium is introduced by one of the most brutal episodes in the Histories: the Greek and Carian mercenaries in Egyptian service, furious at Phanes for betraying them to a foreign army, seized his children whom he had left behind in Egypt and killed them in front of him between the armies — mixing their blood with wine and water and drinking it before the battle as a kind of imprecatory oath. Then the battle was fought with great stubbornness, many falling on both sides, until the Egyptians broke and fled. The horror of the prologue casts its shadow over the whole engagement.

Persian and Egyptian skulls

A characteristic Herodotean digression from an autopsy: the bones of the Persian and Egyptian dead still lay separately on the battlefield, and Herodotus reports testing them. Persian skulls could be holed with a pebble; Egyptian skulls were so thick you could barely crack them with a large stone. The explanation given by the locals, and accepted by Herodotus: Egyptians shave their heads from childhood and the bone thickens in the sun, which also prevents baldness; Persians wear felt tiaras from birth and keep their skulls in the shade, hence soft bone. Herodotus saw the same contrast at Papremis.

The fall of Memphis

After the flight from Pelusium the Egyptians fell back on Memphis. Cambyses sent a Mytilenian ship upriver with a Persian herald to negotiate surrender. The Egyptians' response was to destroy the ship and kill or dismember its entire crew. The siege that followed ended in submission. The Libyans neighbouring Egypt, terrified by what had happened, immediately gave themselves up without fighting and paid tribute; the Kyrenians and Barcans sent money. Cambyses scattered the Kyrenian silver among his soldiers, apparently judging it insultingly small.

Cambyses tests Psammenitos

One of the most famous passages in the Histories: Cambyses' deliberate psychological test of the defeated pharaoh Psammenitos. His daughter walked past as a water-carrier slave; Psammenitos bowed to the earth and wept. His son was led past to execution with two thousand other young Egyptians. Psammenitos did the same. Then an old friend — a table companion now reduced to beggary — passed by, and Psammenitos cried out, called him by name, and beat his head. Spies reported this to Cambyses, who asked: why silent for your children but weeping for a beggar? The answer Psammenitos gave has been remembered for twenty-four centuries.

The end of Psammenitos

The answer Psammenitos gave about the beggar moved even Cambyses to pity; he ordered Psammenitos's son saved from the execution party. But the messengers arrived too late — the son had been executed first. Psammenitos was brought into Cambyses' presence and treated without violence, living at court. Herodotus digresses to note that the Persians regularly restore power to the sons of defeated kings, citing Thannyras son of Inaros and Pausiris son of Amyrtaios as examples. Psammenitos, however, was caught inciting revolt and died by drinking bull's blood.

Cambyses desecrates Amasis's corpse

Cambyses' treatment of Amasis's corpse is one of the key exhibits in Herodotus's emerging portrait of the king as impious and erratic. Cambyses ordered the body exhumed, scourged, stabbed, defiled in every possible way, then burned. Both Persians and Egyptians regard burning corpses as sacrilege for different reasons: Persians because fire is a god; Egyptians because fire is a beast that devours and dies with what it eats, whereas embalming protects the dead from being consumed by worms. Herodotus adds that the Egyptians claim the body Cambyses burned was a substitute — Amasis foresaw the outrage by oracle and arranged for a different corpse to be buried in his place. Herodotus does not believe this.

Three expeditions planned

The overreach that the doctrine of hubris and reversal demands: Cambyses, having conquered Egypt, immediately plans three more campaigns in different directions at once. The naval force is directed against Carthage; a land force against the Ammonians; and spies — fronting as gift-bearers — are sent to the Long-lived Ethiopians to verify the legend of the Table of the Sun and reconnoitre their kingdom. The three-campaign plan, launched simultaneously, is the structural echo of Xerxes's later decisions: a conqueror who cannot stop conquering is the figure most exposed to reversal.

The Table of the Sun

A brief ethnographic vignette on the Table of the Sun — the legendary meadow in the suburbs of the Ethiopian city that was said to fill nightly with cooked meat of every four-footed animal by the agency of those citizens in authority, and to be available by day to any comer as a free communal meal. The Ethiopians, Herodotus notes, say that the earth herself produces these things. The legend had circulated widely enough that it was one of the specific intelligence targets of Cambyses' spy mission. Its fabulous quality signals that the Ethiopians in this episode are as much a counter-image to Persian imperial practice as they are a real people.

The fleet abandons Carthage

One of the three planned campaigns is immediately cancelled. Cambyses had ordered his fleet to attack Carthage, but the Phoenician component — the backbone of Persian naval power — refused: Carthage was a Phoenician colony and they were bound by solemn vows not to attack their own descendants. Without the Phoenicians the rest of the fleet was insufficient. Cambyses, Herodotus notes, judged it wrong to apply compulsion to the Phoenicians, because they had surrendered to Persia voluntarily and the whole naval force depended on them. Carthage accordingly escaped Persian conquest — and so, incidentally, did the western Mediterranean.

The spy mission

The spy mission is assembled and dispatched. Cambyses first summons the Ichthyophagoi — the Fish-Eaters — of Elephantine who speak Ethiopian, to serve as interpreters. Then he sends them bearing a selection of Persian luxury goods: a purple garment, a twisted gold collar, bracelets, a box of perfumed ointment, and palm-wine. Herodotus adds an ethnographic note: the Long-lived Ethiopians are said to be the tallest and most beautiful of all men, and their custom of kingship is distinctive — they crown whoever among them is tallest and has strength proportional to his height. The gift list and the customs of the recipient people are set up in deliberate contrast to what follows.

The Ethiopian king sees through the embassy

The Ethiopian king is presented as Herodotus's ideal of uncorrupted natural sovereignty: he perceives the Fish-Eaters are spies, says so directly, and delivers a moral rebuke to Cambyses through them. He takes the Persian gifts one by one and interrogates them: the purple cloth — deceitful, like the men who made it; the gold — fetters, which his own country has stronger versions of. He then draws a bow of his own, bends it, and hands it over: tell Cambyses to march when Persians can draw a bow like this. The speech is one of the most compressed moral arguments in the Histories.

The Ethiopian king interrogates the gifts

After the bow challenge, the Ethiopian king cross-examines the Fish-Eaters about Persian customs. Learning that the purple dye was produced by tricks on a sea-creature, he calls it deceitful. Learning that the gold jewellery is ornament and not actually chains, he laughs and says his country has stronger fetters. Learning that the ointment is refined and perfumed, he makes the same comment as about the cloth. Then the wine genuinely pleases him. He asks what Persians eat and learns of bread — grain grown in soil, which he characterises as 'dung.' And he asks how long Persians live: eighty years is the most. He says he is not surprised they live so few years when they feed upon dung; if not for the wine they would not manage even that many.

The Ethiopian king's country

The Fish-Eaters, having received the king's rebuff, were shown the marvels of his kingdom. He led them to a spring whose water was so light that nothing floated on it — not even wood — and so fragrant it smelled of violets; the Ethiopians washed in it and it made their skin sleek. He then led them to the prison, where all the prisoners were bound in fetters of gold — the rarest and most precious metal in Ethiopia, which uses bronze as Persia uses iron. The chapter closes with a glimpse of the Table of the Sun. The contrast between Ethiopian simplicity and Persian elaboration reaches its symbolic peak: the most valuable substance in the world is here used to chain prisoners because among this people bronze, not gold, is the scarce metal.

Crystal Coffins of the Ethiopians

Cambyses Marches into Ethiopia

The Lost Army of the Ammonians

Cambyses Confronts the Sacred Bull Apis

Cambyses Summons the Apis Bull

Cambyses Wounds the Sacred Bull

The Onset of Cambyses's Madness

Cambyses Murders His Sister-Wife

Two Accounts of the Sister's Death

Herodotus on Cambyses's Madness

Cambyses Tests Prexaspes with an Arrow

The Arrow in the Heart of Prexaspes's Son

Croesus Rebukes Cambyses and Nearly Dies for It

Cambyses Desecrates Tombs and Temples at Memphis

Herodotus on the Relativity of Custom

Polycrates, Tyrant of Samos

Amasis Warns Polycrates to Sacrifice His Fortune

Polycrates and the Ring Cast into the Sea

The Fish Returns the Ring

Amasis Dissolves the Guest-Friendship

The Spartan Expedition Against Samos

Conflicting Accounts of the Samian Exiles

The Samian Exiles' Appeal to Sparta

The Spartan and Samian Reasons for the Expedition

Corinth Joins the Expedition Against Samos

The Corcyra-Corinth Feud

Periander, Melissa, and the Prophecy About Lycophron

Lycophron's Unyielding Silence Toward His Father

Periander Isolates Lycophron Through Proclamation

Lycophron Agrees to Return — and Is Killed

the-histories-book-3-chapter-54

the-histories-book-3-chapter-55

the-histories-book-3-chapter-56

the-histories-book-3-chapter-57

the-histories-book-3-chapter-58

the-histories-book-3-chapter-59

the-histories-book-3-chapter-60

the-histories-book-3-chapter-61

the-histories-book-3-chapter-62

the-histories-book-3-chapter-63

the-histories-book-3-chapter-64

the-histories-book-3-chapter-65

the-histories-book-3-chapter-66

the-histories-book-3-chapter-67

the-histories-book-3-chapter-68

the-histories-book-3-chapter-69

the-histories-book-3-chapter-70

the-histories-book-3-chapter-71

the-histories-book-3-chapter-72

the-histories-book-3-chapter-73

the-histories-book-3-chapter-74

the-histories-book-3-chapter-75

the-histories-book-3-chapter-76

the-histories-book-3-chapter-77

the-histories-book-3-chapter-78

the-histories-book-3-chapter-79

the-histories-book-3-chapter-80

the-histories-book-3-chapter-81

the-histories-book-3-chapter-82

the-histories-book-3-chapter-83

the-histories-book-3-chapter-84

the-histories-book-3-chapter-85

the-histories-book-3-chapter-86

the-histories-book-3-chapter-87

the-histories-book-3-chapter-88

the-histories-book-3-chapter-89

the-histories-book-3-chapter-90

the-histories-book-3-chapter-91

the-histories-book-3-chapter-92

the-histories-book-3-chapter-93

the-histories-book-3-chapter-94

the-histories-book-3-chapter-95

the-histories-book-3-chapter-96

the-histories-book-3-chapter-97

the-histories-book-3-chapter-98

the-histories-book-3-chapter-99

the-histories-book-3-chapter-100

the-histories-book-3-chapter-101

the-histories-book-3-chapter-102

the-histories-book-3-chapter-103

the-histories-book-3-chapter-104

the-histories-book-3-chapter-105

the-histories-book-3-chapter-106

the-histories-book-3-chapter-107

the-histories-book-3-chapter-108

the-histories-book-3-chapter-109

the-histories-book-3-chapter-110

the-histories-book-3-chapter-111

the-histories-book-3-chapter-112

the-histories-book-3-chapter-113

the-histories-chapter-511-ethiopia-furthest-lands

the-histories-chapter-512-europe-northern-extremities-eridanos

the-histories-chapter-513-arimaspians-griffins-gold

the-histories-chapter-514-chorasmian-plain-persian-water

the-histories-chapter-515-intaphrenes-execution-royal-court

the-histories-chapter-516-wife-intaphrenes-saves-brother

the-histories-chapter-517-oroites-satrap-polycrates

the-histories-chapter-518-polycrates-anacreon-oroites-message

the-histories-chapter-519-polycrates-downfall-two-accounts

the-histories-chapter-520-maiandrios-polycrates-plans-journey

the-histories-chapter-521-polycrates-daughter-dream-omen

the-histories-chapter-522-death-polycrates-magnesia

the-histories-chapter-523-oroites-retribution-darius-vengeance

the-histories-chapter-524-darius-strategy-oroites-guards

the-histories-chapter-525-bagaios-lot-oroites-assassinated

the-histories-chapter-526-darius-ankle-demokedes-physician

the-histories-chapter-527-demokedes-heals-darius-royal-favour

the-histories-chapter-528-demokedes-career-croton-aegina-athens

the-histories-chapter-529-demokedes-susa-saves-egyptian-doctors

the-histories-chapter-530-atossa-tumour-demokedes-opportunity

the-histories-chapter-531-atossa-urges-darius-invade-greece

the-histories-chapter-532-fifteen-persians-spy-greece-demokedes

the-histories-chapter-533-persian-expedition-greek-coastal-survey

the-histories-chapter-534-demokedes-escapes-croton-defends

the-histories-chapter-535-gillos-tarentine-rescues-persians

the-histories-chapter-536-darius-takes-samos-syloson

the-histories-chapter-537-syloson-court-darius-gift-remembered

the-histories-chapter-538-otanes-persian-expedition-samos

the-histories-chapter-539-maiandrios-samos-attempted-justice

the-histories-chapter-540-maiandrios-abandons-justice-holds-power

the-histories/book-3-chapter-144

the-histories/book-3-chapter-145

the-histories/book-3-chapter-146

the-histories/book-3-chapter-147

the-histories/book-3-chapter-148

the-histories/book-3-chapter-149

the-histories/book-3-chapter-150

the-histories/book-3-chapter-151

the-histories/book-3-chapter-152

the-histories/book-3-chapter-153

the-histories/book-3-chapter-154

the-histories/book-3-chapter-155

the-histories/book-3-chapter-156

the-histories/book-3-chapter-157

the-histories/book-3-chapter-158

the-histories/book-3-chapter-159

the-histories/book-3-chapter-160

the-histories/book-4-chapter-1

the-histories/book-4-chapter-2

the-histories/book-4-chapter-3

the-histories/book-4-chapter-4

the-histories/book-4-chapter-5

the-histories/book-4-chapter-6

the-histories/book-4-chapter-7

the-histories/book-4-chapter-8

the-histories/book-4-chapter-9

the-histories/book-4-chapter-10

the-histories/book-4-chapter-11

the-histories/book-4-chapter-12

the-histories/book-4-chapter-13

the-histories-book-4-chapter-14

the-histories-book-4-chapter-15

the-histories-book-4-chapter-16

the-histories-book-4-chapter-17

the-histories-book-4-chapter-19

the-histories-book-4-chapter-20

the-histories-book-4-chapter-21

the-histories-book-4-chapter-22

the-histories-book-4-chapter-23

the-histories-book-4-chapter-24

the-histories-book-4-chapter-25

the-histories-book-4-chapter-26

the-histories-book-4-chapter-27

the-histories-book-4-chapter-28

the-histories-book-4-chapter-29

the-histories-book-4-chapter-30

the-histories-book-4-chapter-31

the-histories-book-4-chapter-32

the-histories-book-4-chapter-33

the-histories-book-4-chapter-34

the-histories-book-4-chapter-35

the-histories-book-4-chapter-36

the-histories-book-4-chapter-37

the-histories-book-4-chapter-38

the-histories-book-4-chapter-39

the-histories-book-4-chapter-40

the-histories-book-4-chapter-41

the-histories-book-4-chapter-42

the-histories-book-4-chapter-43

the-histories-book-4-chapter-44

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-45

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-46

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-47

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-48

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-49

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-50

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-51

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-52

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-53

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-54

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-55

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-56

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-57

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-58

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-59

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-60

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-61

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-62

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-63

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-64

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-65

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-66

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-67

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-68

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-69

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-70

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-71

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-72

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-73

the-histories-book-iv-chapter-74

the-histories-book-4-chapter-75

the-histories-book-4-chapter-76

the-histories-book-4-chapter-77

the-histories-book-4-chapter-78

the-histories-book-4-chapter-79

the-histories-book-4-chapter-80

the-histories-book-4-chapter-81

the-histories-book-4-chapter-82

the-histories-book-4-chapter-83

the-histories-book-4-chapter-84

the-histories-book-4-chapter-85

the-histories-book-4-chapter-86

the-histories-book-4-chapter-87

the-histories-book-4-chapter-88

the-histories-book-4-chapter-89

the-histories-book-4-chapter-90

the-histories-book-4-chapter-91

the-histories-book-4-chapter-92

the-histories-book-4-chapter-93

the-histories-book-4-chapter-94

the-histories-book-4-chapter-95

the-histories-book-4-chapter-96

the-histories-book-4-chapter-97

the-histories-book-4-chapter-98

the-histories-book-4-chapter-99

the-histories-book-4-chapter-100

the-histories-book-4-chapter-101

the-histories-book-4-chapter-102

the-histories-book-4-chapter-103

the-histories-book-4-chapter-104

book-4-chapter-105

book-4-chapter-106

book-4-chapter-107

book-4-chapter-108

book-4-chapter-109

book-4-chapter-110

book-4-chapter-111

book-4-chapter-112

book-4-chapter-113

book-4-chapter-114

book-4-chapter-115

book-4-chapter-116

book-4-chapter-117

book-4-chapter-118

book-4-chapter-119

book-4-chapter-120

book-4-chapter-121

book-4-chapter-122

book-4-chapter-123

book-4-chapter-124

book-4-chapter-125

book-4-chapter-126

book-4-chapter-127

book-4-chapter-128

book-4-chapter-129

book-4-chapter-130

book-4-chapter-131

book-4-chapter-132

book-4-chapter-133

book-4-chapter-134

book-iv-chapter-135

book-iv-chapter-136

book-iv-chapter-137

book-iv-chapter-138

book-iv-chapter-139

book-iv-chapter-140

book-iv-chapter-141

book-iv-chapter-142

book-iv-chapter-143

book-iv-chapter-144

book-iv-chapter-145

book-iv-chapter-146

book-iv-chapter-147

book-iv-chapter-148

book-iv-chapter-149

book-iv-chapter-150

book-iv-chapter-151

book-iv-chapter-152

book-iv-chapter-153

book-iv-chapter-154

book-iv-chapter-155

book-iv-chapter-156

book-iv-chapter-157

book-iv-chapter-158

book-iv-chapter-159

book-iv-chapter-160

book-iv-chapter-161

book-iv-chapter-162

book-iv-chapter-163

book-iv-chapter-164

Book 4, Chapter 165 — Pheretime Flees to Egypt

Book 4, Chapter 166 — Aryandes Imitates Darius and Is Executed

Book 4, Chapter 167 — Persian Army Dispatched to Barca

Book 4, Chapter 168 — The Adyrmachidai of Libya

Book 4, Chapter 169 — The Giligamai and the Silphion Region

Book 4, Chapter 170 — The Asbystai and Their Four-Horse Chariots

Book 4, Chapter 171 — The Auchisai and Bacales

Book 4, Chapter 172 — The Nasamonians: Locust-Eaters and Oath-Takers

Book 4, Chapter 173 — The Psylloi: Destroyed by the South Wind

Book 4, Chapter 174 — The Garamantians: A Reclusive Desert People

Book 4, Chapter 175 — The Macai and the River Kinyps

Book 4, Chapter 176 — The Gindanes: Women Who Count Their Lovers

Book 4, Chapter 177 — The Lotophagoi: Eaters of the Lotus

Book 4, Chapter 178 — The Machlyans and Lake Tritonis

Book 4, Chapter 179 — Jason and the Argo at Lake Tritonis

Book 4, Chapter 180 — The Auseans and the Festival of Athene

Book 4, Chapter 181 — The Belt of Sand and the Salt Hills of the Interior

Book 4, Chapter 182 — Augila: The Oasis of the Nasamonians

Book 4, Chapter 183 — The Garamantians of the Interior

Book 4, Chapter 184 — The Atarantians: A People Without Personal Names

Book 4, Chapter 185 — The Limit of Herodotus's Libyan Knowledge

Book 4, Chapter 186 — Libyan Dietary Taboos and Egyptian Influence

Book 4, Chapter 187 — Libyan Child-Rearing and Cauterisation

Book 4, Chapter 188 — Libyan Sacrifice and Religion

Book 4, Chapter 189 — Athene's Dress Derived from Libyan Women

Book 4, Chapter 190 — Nomadic Libyan Burial Customs

Book 4, Chapter 191 — The Maxyans: Settled Farmers Who Claim Trojan Origin

Book 4, Chapter 192 — Fauna of the Libyan Interior

Book 4, Chapter 193 — The Zauekes: Women as Charioteers in War

Book 4, Chapter 194 — The Gyzantes: Beekeepers Who Eat Monkeys

book-iv-melpomene-chapter-195

book-iv-melpomene-chapter-196

book-iv-melpomene-chapter-197

book-iv-melpomene-chapter-198

book-iv-melpomene-chapter-199

book-iv-melpomene-chapter-200

book-iv-melpomene-chapter-201

book-iv-melpomene-chapter-202

book-iv-melpomene-chapter-203

book-iv-melpomene-chapter-204

book-iv-melpomene-chapter-205

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-1

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-2

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-3

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-4

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-5

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-6

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-7

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-8

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-9

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-10

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-11

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-12

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-13

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-14

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-15

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-16

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-17

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-18

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-19

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-20

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-21

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-22

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-23

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-24

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-25

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-26

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-27

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-28

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-29

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-30

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-31

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-32

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-33

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-34

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-35

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-36

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-37

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-38

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-39

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-40

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-41

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-42

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-43

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-44

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-45

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-46

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-47

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-48

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-49

book-v-chapter-50

book-v-chapter-51

book-v-chapter-52

book-v-chapter-53

book-v-chapter-54

book-v-chapter-55

book-v-chapter-56

book-v-chapter-57

book-v-chapter-58

book-v-chapter-59

book-v-chapter-60

book-v-chapter-61

book-v-chapter-62

book-v-chapter-63

book-v-chapter-64

book-v-chapter-65

book-v-chapter-66

book-v-chapter-67

book-v-chapter-68

book-v-chapter-69

book-v-chapter-70

book-v-chapter-71

book-v-chapter-72

book-v-chapter-73

book-v-chapter-74

book-v-chapter-75

book-v-chapter-76

book-v-chapter-77

book-v-chapter-78

book-v-chapter-79

book-v-chapter-80

book-v-chapter-81

book-v-chapter-82

book-v-chapter-83

book-v-chapter-84

book-v-chapter-85

book-v-chapter-86

book-v-chapter-87

book-v-chapter-88

book-v-chapter-89

book-v-chapter-90

book-v-chapter-91

book-v-chapter-92

book-v-chapter-93

book-v-chapter-94

book-v-chapter-95

book-v-chapter-96

book-v-chapter-97

book-v-chapter-98

book-v-chapter-99

book-v-chapter-100

book-v-chapter-101

book-v-chapter-102

book-v-chapter-103

book-v-chapter-104

book-v-chapter-105

book-v-chapter-106

book-v-chapter-107

book-v-chapter-108

book-v-chapter-109

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-110

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-111

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-112

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-113

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-114

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-115

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-116

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-117

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-119

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-120

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-121

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-122

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-123

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-124

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-125

book-v-terpsichore-chapter-126

book-vi-erato-chapter-1

book-vi-erato-chapter-2

book-vi-erato-chapter-3

book-vi-erato-chapter-4

book-vi-erato-chapter-5

book-vi-erato-chapter-6

book-vi-erato-chapter-7

book-vi-erato-chapter-8

book-vi-erato-chapter-9

book-vi-erato-chapter-10

book-vi-erato-chapter-11

book-vi-erato-chapter-12

book-vi-erato-chapter-13

book-vi-erato-chapter-14

book-vi-erato-chapter-15

book-vi-erato-chapter-16

book-vi-erato-chapter-17

book-vi-erato-chapter-18

book-vi-erato-chapter-19

book-vi-erato-chapter-20

book-vi-erato-chapter-21

book-vi-erato-chapter-22

book-vi-erato-chapter-23

book-vi-erato-chapter-24

book-vi-erato-chapter-25

book-vi-erato-chapter-26

book-vi-erato-chapter-27

book-vi-erato-chapter-28

book-vi-erato-chapter-29

book-vi-erato-chapter-30

book-vi-erato-chapter-31

book-vi-erato-chapter-32

book-vi-erato-chapter-33

book-vi-erato-chapter-34

book-vi-erato-chapter-35

book-vi-erato-chapter-36

book-vi-erato-chapter-37

book-vi-erato-chapter-38

book-vi-erato-chapter-39

book-vi-erato-chapter-40

book-vi-erato-chapter-41

book-vi-erato-chapter-42

book-vi-erato-chapter-43

book-vi-erato-chapter-44

book-vi-erato-chapter-45

book-vi-erato-chapter-46

book-vi-erato-chapter-47

book-vi-erato-chapter-48

book-vi-erato-chapter-49

book-vi-erato-chapter-50

book-vi-erato-chapter-51

book-vi-erato-chapter-52

book-vi-erato-chapter-53

book-vi-erato-chapter-54

book-vi-erato-chapter-55

book-vi-erato-chapter-56

book-vi-erato-chapter-57

book-vi-erato-chapter-58

book-vi-erato-chapter-59

book-vi-erato-chapter-60

book-vi-erato-chapter-61

book-vi-erato-chapter-62

book-vi-erato-chapter-63

book-vi-erato-chapter-64

book-vi-erato-chapter-65

book-vi-erato-chapter-66

book-vi-erato-chapter-67

book-vi-erato-chapter-68

book-vi-erato-chapter-69

book-vi-erato-chapter-70

book-vi-erato-chapter-71

book-vi-erato-chapter-72

book-vi-erato-chapter-73

book-vi-erato-chapter-74

cleomenes-madness-death

cleomenes-oracle-argos

battle-sepeia-argives-routed

cleomenes-ruse-herald-cry

cleomenes-sacred-grove-lure

cleomenes-burns-grove-argos

cleomenes-denied-hera

cleomenes-defends-ephors

argos-after-sepeia-slaves

cleomenes-madness-explanations

egina-hostages-leotychides

glaukos-sacred-deposit

egina-attacks-athens-sacred-ship

nicodromos-athenian-agent-egina

nicodromos-revolt-fails

nicodromos-sunion-athenian-atrocity

eginetan-oligarchs-massacre

athens-egina-sea-battle-argive-refusal

egina-defeats-athens-sea

darius-prepares-expedition-athens

persian-fleet-assembles-cilicia

naxos-taken-delos-reverenced

delos-earthquake-omen

persian-fleet-island-hostages

persian-fleet-reaches-eretria

eretria-betrayed-burned

persians-land-marathon

hippias-dream-athenians-marathon

athenian-generals-marathon-miltiades

miltiades-background-escape-persians

the-histories-book-6-chapter-105

the-histories-book-6-chapter-106

the-histories-book-6-chapter-107

the-histories-book-6-chapter-108

the-histories-book-6-chapter-109

the-histories-book-6-chapter-110

the-histories-book-6-chapter-111

the-histories-book-6-chapter-112

the-histories-book-6-chapter-113

the-histories-book-6-chapter-114

the-histories-book-6-chapter-115

the-histories-book-6-chapter-116

the-histories-book-6-chapter-117

the-histories-book-6-chapter-118

the-histories-book-6-chapter-119

the-histories-book-6-chapter-120

the-histories-book-6-chapter-121

the-histories-book-6-chapter-122

the-histories-book-6-chapter-123

the-histories-book-6-chapter-124

the-histories-book-6-chapter-125

the-histories-book-6-chapter-126

the-histories-book-6-chapter-127

the-histories-book-6-chapter-128

the-histories-book-6-chapter-129

the-histories-book-6-chapter-130

the-histories-book-6-chapter-131

the-histories-book-6-chapter-132

the-histories-book-6-chapter-133

the-histories-book-6-chapter-134

book-vi-erato-chapter-135

book-vi-erato-chapter-136

book-vi-erato-chapter-137

book-vi-erato-chapter-138

book-vi-erato-chapter-139

book-vi-erato-chapter-140

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-1

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-2

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-3

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-4

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-5

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-6

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-7

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-8

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-9

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-10

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-11

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-12

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-13

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-14

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-15

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-16

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-17

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-18

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-19

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-20

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-21

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-22

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-23

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-24

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-25

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-26

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-27

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-28

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-29

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-30

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-31

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-32

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-33

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-34

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-36

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-37

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-38

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-40

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-41

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-42

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-43

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-44

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-45

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-46

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-47

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-48

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-49

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-50

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-51

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-52

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-53

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-54

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-55

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-56

book-vii-chapter-57

book-vii-chapter-58

book-vii-chapter-59

book-vii-chapter-60

book-vii-chapter-61

book-vii-chapter-62

book-vii-chapter-63

book-vii-chapter-64

book-vii-chapter-65

book-vii-chapter-66

book-vii-chapter-68

book-vii-chapter-69

book-vii-chapter-70

book-vii-chapter-71

book-vii-chapter-72

book-vii-chapter-73

book-vii-chapter-74

book-vii-chapter-75

book-vii-chapter-77

book-vii-chapter-78

book-vii-chapter-79

book-vii-chapter-80

book-vii-chapter-81

book-vii-chapter-82

book-vii-chapter-83

book-vii-chapter-84

book-vii-chapter-85

book-vii-chapter-86

book-vii-chapter-87

book-vii-chapter-88

book-vii-polymnia-89

book-vii-polymnia-90

book-vii-polymnia-91

book-vii-polymnia-92

book-vii-polymnia-93

book-vii-polymnia-94

book-vii-polymnia-95

book-vii-polymnia-96

book-vii-polymnia-97

book-vii-polymnia-98

book-vii-polymnia-99

book-vii-polymnia-100

book-vii-polymnia-101

book-vii-polymnia-102

book-vii-polymnia-103

book-vii-polymnia-104

book-vii-polymnia-105

book-vii-polymnia-106

book-vii-polymnia-107

book-vii-polymnia-108

book-vii-polymnia-109

book-vii-polymnia-110

book-vii-polymnia-111

book-vii-polymnia-112

book-vii-polymnia-113

book-vii-polymnia-114

book-vii-polymnia-115

book-vii-polymnia-116

book-vii-polymnia-117

book-vii-polymnia-118

book-vii-chapter-119

book-vii-chapter-120

book-vii-chapter-121

book-vii-chapter-122

book-vii-chapter-123

book-vii-chapter-124

book-vii-chapter-125

book-vii-chapter-126

book-vii-chapter-127

book-vii-chapter-128

book-vii-chapter-129

book-vii-chapter-130

book-vii-chapter-131

book-vii-chapter-132

book-vii-chapter-133

book-vii-chapter-134

book-vii-chapter-135

book-vii-chapter-136

book-vii-chapter-137

book-vii-chapter-138

book-vii-chapter-139

book-vii-chapter-140

book-vii-chapter-141

book-vii-chapter-142

book-vii-chapter-143

book-vii-chapter-144

book-vii-chapter-145

book-vii-chapter-146

book-vii-chapter-147

book-vii-chapter-148

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-149

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-150

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-151

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-152

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-153

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-154

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-155

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-156

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-157

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-158

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-159

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-160

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-161

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-162

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-163

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-164

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-165

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-166

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-167

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-168

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-169

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-170

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-171

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-172

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-173

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-174

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-175

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-176

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-177

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-178

book-7-chapter-179

book-7-chapter-180

book-7-chapter-181

book-7-chapter-182

book-7-chapter-183

book-7-chapter-184

book-7-chapter-185

book-7-chapter-186

book-7-chapter-187

book-7-chapter-188

book-7-chapter-189

book-7-chapter-190

book-7-chapter-191

book-7-chapter-192

book-7-chapter-193

book-7-chapter-194

book-7-chapter-195

book-7-chapter-196

book-7-chapter-197

book-7-chapter-198

book-7-chapter-199

book-7-chapter-200

book-7-chapter-201

book-7-chapter-202

book-7-chapter-203

book-7-chapter-204

book-7-chapter-205

book-7-chapter-206

book-7-chapter-207

book-7-chapter-208

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-209

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-210

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-211

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-212

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-213

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-214

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-215

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-217

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-218

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-219

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-220

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-221

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-222

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-223

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-224

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-225

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-226

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-227

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-228

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-229

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-230

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-231

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-232

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-233

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-234

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-235

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-236

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-237

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-238

book-vii-polymnia-chapter-239

book-8-chapter-1

book-8-chapter-2

book-8-chapter-3

book-8-chapter-4

book-8-chapter-5

book-8-chapter-6

book-8-chapter-7

book-8-chapter-8

book-8-chapter-9

book-8-chapter-10

book-8-chapter-11

book-8-chapter-12

book-8-chapter-13

book-8-chapter-14

book-8-chapter-15

book-8-chapter-16

book-8-chapter-17

book-8-chapter-18

book-8-chapter-19

book-8-chapter-20

book-8-chapter-21

book-8-chapter-22

book-8-chapter-23

book-8-chapter-24

book-8-chapter-25

book-8-chapter-26

book-8-chapter-27

book-8-chapter-28

book-8-chapter-29

book-8-chapter-30

Book 8, Chapter 31 — Thessalian Guides and the Dorian Corridor

Book 8, Chapter 32 — The Devastation of Phokis Begins

Book 8, Chapter 33 — Cities of Phokis Burned; Apollo's Temple at Abai Plundered

Book 8, Chapter 34 — The Army Divides at Panopeus; Boeotia Submits

Book 8, Chapter 35 — The Detachment Marches on Delphi

Book 8, Chapter 36 — Delphi Consults Apollo; the God Claims His Own Defense

Book 8, Chapter 37 — Divine Signs Before the Temple of Pronaia

Book 8, Chapter 38 — The Persians Flee Delphi; Miraculous Defenders Appear

Book 8, Chapter 39 — The Heroes Phylacos and Autonoös; Rocks Preserved as Evidence

Book 8, Chapter 40 — The Greek Fleet Moves to Salamis; Athens Considers Its Options

Book 8, Chapter 41 — Athens Evacuated; the Sacred Serpent Refuses Its Honey-Cake

Book 8, Chapter 42 — The Full Greek Fleet Assembles at Salamis; Eurybiades Commands

Book 8, Chapter 43 — Peloponnesian Contingents at Salamis

Book 8, Chapter 44 — The Athenian Contingent; the Pelasgian Origins of Attica

Book 8, Chapter 45 — Megarian, Amprakiot, and Leucadian Contingents

Book 8, Chapter 46 — Island Contingents: Aegina, Chalkis, Eretria, Keos, Naxos

Book 8, Chapter 47 — Croton Sends One Ship; Phaÿllos the Pythian Victor

Book 8, Chapter 48 — Fifty-Oared Galleys; Total Ships at Salamis: 378

Book 8, Chapter 49 — Council Debate: Salamis or the Isthmus?

Book 8, Chapter 50 — News: Xerxes Has Reached Attica; Thespiai and Plataea Burned

Book 8, Chapter 51 — The Persians Reach Athens; the Acropolis Last Defenders

Book 8, Chapter 52 — The Siege of the Acropolis; Fire-Arrows Against the Palisade

Book 8, Chapter 53 — The Acropolis Falls; Persian Soldiers Climb the Unguarded Cliff

Book 8, Chapter 54 — Xerxes Reports to Susa; Orders Athenian Exiles to Sacrifice

Book 8, Chapter 55 — Athena's Olive Tree Sprouts Overnight After the Burning

Book 8, Chapter 56 — The Greeks at Salamis Learn Athens Has Fallen; Commanders Begin to Flee

Book 8, Chapter 57 — Mnesiphilos Advises Themistocles to Reconvene the Council

Book 8, Chapter 58 — Themistocles Presents Mnesiphilos's Arguments as His Own

Book 8, Chapter 59 — Themistocles Speaks Before His Turn; the Corinthian's Rebuke

Book 8, Chapter 60 — Themistocles Makes the Strategic Case for Fighting at Salamis

book-viii-chapter-61

book-viii-chapter-62

book-viii-chapter-63

book-viii-chapter-64

book-viii-chapter-65

book-viii-chapter-66

book-viii-chapter-67

book-viii-chapter-68